Behavior of neuropathic pain in mice following chronic constriction injury comparing silk and catgut ligatures
© van der Wal et al.; licensee Springer. 2015
Received: 10 February 2015
Accepted: 29 April 2015
Published: 15 May 2015
Neuropathic pain is defined as pain arising as a direct consequence of a lesion or disease affecting the somatosensory system and is common after surgery. Neuropathic pain can persist without an obvious injury. In this study we aim to validate a murine chronic constriction injury model as a model for neuropathic pain research and determine if silk or catgut ligatures induced most stable neuropathic pain behavior.
In this study mice underwent chronic constriction or sham surgery. Mice were tested on cutaneous hyperalgesia with the cumulative reaction time in the acetone test, on allodynia with the cumulative reaction time and number of lifts in the cold plate test and the maximal force before withdrawal in von Frey test.
In the acetone test neuropathic pain was seen in CCI mice, but not in sham mice. Hyperalgesia was present postoperatively in CCI mice compared with preoperatively. In the cold plate test cumulative reaction time and number of lifts were higher in the ipsilateral hind paw than in the contralateral hind paw and sham mice. Postoperative measurements were higher than preoperatively. In the von Frey test the postoperative measurements were lower in the ipsilateral hind paw than preoperatively, while the contralateral hind paw showed an increase in maximal force before withdrawal. The contralateral hind paw showed more difference with sham mice than the ipsilateral hind paw. Silk ligatures showed more stable neuropathic pain behavior. In the acetone test, the cold plate test and the von Frey test the mice scored higher on neuropathic pain having silk ligatures, compared with catgut ligatures.
In this study we validated a murine CCI model for neuropathic pain behavior. In the murine CCI model it appears that silk ligatures demonstrate more stable neuropathic pain behaviors than catgut ligatures in de CCI model.
KeywordsAllodynia Catgut Hyperalgesia Neuropathic pain Silk
Neuropathic pain is defined as pain arising as a consequence of a lesion or disease affecting the somatosensory system and is common after surgery (Treede et al. 2008). Neuropathic pain presents as a constant, burning pain with spontaneous sharp exacerbations and worsening upon normal sensory triggers (Dieleman et al. 2008).
The grading system of neuropathic pain is based on certain criteria, explained by Treede (Treede et al. 2008). The criteria consist of the distribution of pain coupled to the medical history and clinical investigation with supplemental sensory testing. Depending on the number of criteria that match with the patient, neuropathic pain is confirmed or excluded (Treede et al. 2008). Sensory testing is an important diagnostic tool in determination of neuropathic pain and allodynia and hyperalgesia should be determined (Macrae 2001).
Neuropathic pain is associated with poor physical and mental health and adversely affects quality of life (Freynhagen & Bennett 2009; Leung & CM Cahill 2010). The prevalence of neuropathic pain in the human population ranges from 1 to 17.9% (Hecke van, O et al. 2013). considering the above neuropathic pain adds to the burden of direct and indirect medical cost for our society (Leung & C.M. Cahill 2010), as there are direct medical costs, loss of the ability to work, loss of caregivers' ability to work and possibly greater need for institutionalization or other living assistance (O'Connor 2009).
The treatment of neuropathic pain mostly consists of oral analgesics such as tricyclic anti-depressants (TCAs) and anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs) (Allen 2005), to decrease the symptoms of neuropathic pain. However, the therapeutic response on the pharmacological treatment of neuropathic pain is rather poor, as few patients receive efficacious dosages of medication (Dieleman et al. 2008; O'Connor 2009).
Because the mechanisms of neuropathic pain are insufficiently understood, (Clark et al. 2013; Thacker et al. 2007) it seems pivotal to investigate the course and cause of neuropathic pain and development of treatment and perhaps prevention strategies. Therefore ideally we want to study a neuropathic pain animal model extrapolatable to the clinical situation. Often a chronic constrictive injury model is used in rats to study neuropathic pain which include thermal and mechanical allodynia testing (Bennett & Xie 1988; Mogil 2009). In this study we aim to validate a chronic constriction model in mice. A murine model can lead to a better understanding of the course of neuropathic pain, and will lead to an improvement of accuracy and variability of the chronic constriction model, because of the possibility to use transgenic mice (Mogil 2009).
The material that is used for ligatures can have an effect on the outcome of the observed sensory abnormalities (Robinson & Meert 2005). In chronic constriction injury, either catgut or silk ligatures are used. In rats, catgut is commonly used as ligature material (Gabay & Tal 2004). Catgut leads to a development of an inflammatory reaction and consequentially a loss of most A-fibres and some C-fibers, but few cell bodies (Bridges et al. 2001; Selvig et al. 1998). In mice, however, the preferable ligature material is not known. In this research both silk and catgut ligatures were compared, to check for efficacy in inducing neuropathic pain behavior.
In this study we aim to validate a model of neuropathic pain in mice and investigate whether silk or catgut ligature material is more effective in inducing neuropathic pain.
All experiments were approved by the Regional Animal Ethics Committee in Nijmegen and performed under the guidelines of the Dutch Council for Animal Care and The National Institutes of Health.
All studies were performed in C57BL/6J male mice (Charles River). Mice were aged 6 weeks upon arrival were first acclimatized. Mice were housed in a light and temperature controlled room under specific pathogen free (SPF) conditions. Standard pelleted chow (1.00% Ca; 0.22% Mg; 0.24% Na; 0.70% P; 1.02% K; SSNIFF Spezialdiäten GmbH, Soest, Germany) and drinking water were available ad libitum.
This experiment was used to validate the chronic constriction injury (CCI) model in mice (n=45) to induce neuropathic pain. In the experiment postoperative testing was done in both sham-group (n=5) and CCI-group (n=40), with either catgut (n=20) or silk (n=20) ligatures.
Both sham and CCI-mice were being operated. Before surgery, the mice got rimadyl subcutaneously according to their weight (0.1 ml rimadyl per 10 gram). The mice were anesthetized using isofluran inhalation (1–4%). Under a dissecting microscope, the left common sciatic nerve was exposed at the level of the mid-thigh by dissecting through the biceps femoris. In contrary to the sham-mice, in which no ligatures were placed, in de CCI-mice, proximal to the nerve trifurcation (while taking care to preserve epineural circulation), three ligatures (either silk 6.0 or catgut 6.0) were loosely tied around the sciatic nerve, at about 1 mm spacing, until they elicited a brief twitch in the related hind paw. The muscle layer was then stitched and the incision in the shaved skin layer was closed using suture or clips. The sham-operated animals were used as controls and had only sciatic exposure without ligation. Also after surgery the mice got rimadyl subcutaneously according to their weight on day 1 and day 2 once a day. On day 10, the clips were removed. After the experiment, when the mice were euthanized, the nerve histology was studied by removing connective tissue and ligatures.
The first week after surgery, animals will be weighted daily. When the animal loses too much weight (>30% directly after surgery or 20% not directly after surgery, starting weight mean of approximately 24 grams) or does not recover within 1 week the humane endpoint has been reached and the animal will be excluded from the experiment and consequently postoperative pain testing. They were also tested on activity, state of the surgical wound and eventual damage on the left feet or toes (by autotomy).
Responses to thermal and mechanical stimuli were tested in all mice. Sham mice were tested before surgery (baseline) and 3, 7, 10, 14 and 21 days after surgery. CCI-mice were tested before surgery (baseline) and 3, 7, 10, 14, 21 and also 28 days after surgery
Thermal and chemical hyperalgesia were tested using the acetone spray test. After habituation for at least 15 minutes in plexiglass cubicles with a wire mesh metal floor, the plantar area of the left hind paw was exposed to acetone. For one minute the mouse was scored on lifting up the paw, scratching to the paw and touching the left hip or paw. The duration of the reaction was measured and analysed as cumulative reaction time (Vissers & Meert 2005).
Thermal allodynia was measured using the Cold Plate test. The mice were exposed to a temperature of 2–2.5°C to regain the best response. Measurements were performed on both the ipsilateral and contralateral hind paws. Mice were scored for 5 minutes on scratching with a paw, lifting up the paw, lifting up the paw shortly in the same place and licking on the toes. The amount of lifting of the hind paw was measured and analysed as number of lifts. Also the duration of reaction was measured, analysed as cumulative reaction time (Bennett & Xie 1988; Jasmin et al. 1998). However, the cold plate test became defective, so in some groups the number of mice with catgut ligatures is lower.
Number of the von Frey hair with the corresponding weight in grams
Number of the hair
Weight of the hair (g)
Results are presented as mean values ± S.E. All statistical analyses were performed with IBM SPSS Statistics 20 (SPSS, Chicago, IL). Because of some missing data in the CCI group statistical analysis of post- and pre-measurements in the acetone test, cold plate test and the von Frey test were done using linear mixed models. For the analysis of ligature material and the differences between CCI and sham mice a multifactor ANOVA-test is performed. A p-value of 0.05 is considered statistically significant. To determine the experimental group size a calculation on data is performed based on previously published information (Osikowicz et al. 2008), using the following formula: n = 1 + 2C(s/d)2 (Dell et al. 2002) to compute sample size for continuous variables where s is an estimation of the standard deviation of the variable, d is the magnitude of the difference we wish to be detected, and C is a constant dependent on the value of alpha and beta selected. C = 10.5 for α = 0.5 and 1-β = 0.9, then sample size is n = 1 + 21 × (5/10)2 = 6.25. This analysis showed that to detect differences of 10% with a power of 90% and statistical significance at the p < 0.05 level, 7 mice per group is needed. Since we expect that 10–30% of animals that will undergo chronic construction injury will not have successful neuropathic symptoms 10 animals per group will be needed to produce statistically valid results.
There were no complications after surgery and no animals had to be excluded from the study. One mouse got a staphylococcus infection at the end of the experiment, which was treated. The fur of all the mice was clean, shining and well groomed.
Directly after surgery, CCI-mice showed a characteristic posture of the left hind paw, with a curve downward and decreased musculature and thereby made abnormal movements with the left hind paw. After approximately one week, the enlarged movements were still seen and the left hind paw was still curved downwards, but the other abnormal movements mostly disappeared. Some mice showed mild signs of autotomy, as they gnaw or bite their paws or toes, which could indicate that the ligation of the sciatic nerve was too tight. There were occasional signs of stress present, but no abnormal aggression amongst the mice was seen. The activity of the mice was generally normal. Both sham as CCI-mice gained weight during the experiment. After the experiment it was confirmed that constrictions were still present.
Cold plate test
Von Frey test
In this study we demonstrated that a chronic constrictive injury (CCI) model in mice can induce neuropathic pain behaviors comparable to neuropathic pain signs and symptoms in humans. Chronic constriction injury in mice seems to present significant quantitative changes proportional to external stimulation in thermal and chemical hyperalgesia, thermal allodynia and mechanical allodynia. Neuropathy was developed from day 7 postoperatively and in most animals neuropathy was still observed until day 21–27 days postoperatively.
We tested two ligature materials, silk and catgut. Silk seems to be preferable compared with catgut as ligature material in mice.
Neuropathic pain behavior
After surgery abnormal movements were seen in all groups, which disappeared mostly after one week. No mice had to be excluded from the experiment due to extensive weight loss, disease or autotomy. In some mice a slight reddening of the plantar surface of the toes was seen, these mice were not excluded from the experiment. It could however indicate that the ligature of the sciatic nerve was too tight. According to cumulative reaction time, measured with the acetone test, thermal and chemical hyperalgesia were present from day 7 in CCI mice with both silk and catgut ligatures. Sham mice were barely responsive to acetone application, but CCI mice showed associated aversive behavior as licking of the affected paw, limping with the left paw and enlarged movements. The acetone test was only performed in the ipsilateral hind paw, so no comparison with the contralateral hind paw could be made. Also according to both cumulative reaction time and number of lifts, measured with the cold plate test, cold allodynia was present in CCI mice with silk and catgut ligatures from day 7, compared with the contralateral hind paw and the sham mice. And also the von Frey test showed neuropathy in CCI mice with silk catgut ligatures from day 7.
The CCI-model has its limitations. For example, to obtain validated results, environmental factors should be eliminated. Concerning the acetone test the duration of exposure to cold is dependent on the spread and the evaporation of acetone, because of the ambient temperature and the body temperature of the mouse (Allchorne et al. 2005; Tanimoto-Mori et al. 2008). Furthermore the landing of the acetone of the plantar surface of the left hind paw is technique-dependant, and causes differences in mice (Vissers & Meert 2005). Also the liquid itself may elicit a chemical, olfactory or mechanical stimulus that may, independent of the temperature, elicit a flexion reflex (Vissers & Meert 2005; Allchorne et al. 2005; Tanimoto-Mori et al. 2008). Concerning the cold plate testing, not all tests could be performed due to technical difficulties, especially in the catgut-ligatured mice. Cold allodynia in mice can mimic cold allodynia observed in patients (Toyama et al. 2014). Cold plate testing has high behavioral variability and is mainly used for neuropathy models. During cold plate testing we did found high baseline values in the cold plate tests with high variability. Habituation is a contributing factor in the gradual decline of our measurements and perhaps a longer period of acclimatization should be applied to research with cold plate testing in mice (Brenner et al. 2014). Concerning the von Frey testing, the bending forces applied by Von Frey filaments are significantly influenced by ambient humidity and slightly by temperature. Also washing and drying can significantly affect the bending forces (Andrews 1993). It is important the experimenter waits for the animal to hold its paw in the right position as weight bearing of the limb might be a confounding factor in determining von Frey withdrawal thresholds. Therefore also the increased weight of the CCI mice during the experiment could be a determent factor in the von Frey test (Kauppila et al. 1998). In further research it might be useful to use an electronic von Frey meter, because of the difference in increase of the forces.
Silk versus catgut
In the acetone test, the cold plate test and the von Frey test a trend toward more neuropathic behavior was shown in mice with silk ligatures compared with catgut ligatures. Robinson et al. showed catgut ligation caused cold allodynia, chemical hyperalgesia and mechanical hyperalgesia for at least 56 days post-surgery following partial sciatic nerve ligation (PNL) in rat. Silk ligatures caused the same deficits, but several of these deficits diminished over time 21–28 post surgery. In contrary to the rat model, where catgut is mostly used presumably because it induces an inflammatory response, in mice, catgut does not seem to be as effective. Perhaps catgut in mice does not induce an inflammatory response where silk ligature material does (Robinson & Meert 2005). However this research just measured neuropathic pain for 27 days, sham even 21 days, so the long term effect of ligature material on neuropathy is not studied and inflammatory parameters have not been studied. More research is therefore needed to prove our hypothesis that silk is more effective than catgut in mice in a CCI model.
In conclusion this study demonstrated that a murine chronic constriction injury model to study neuropathic pain behavior can be a valuable model for testing of neuropathic pain and observational studies. Because mice are genetically modifiable, chronic constriction injury research in mice could create important opportunities in for example the role of inflammatory receptors or channel pathology compared with other animal models for the further discovering and testing of the mechanisms of neuropathic pain and possible new treatment targets.
No funding was received for this study. All named authors meet the ICMJE criteria for authorship for this manuscript, take responsibility for the integrity of the work as a whole, and have given final approval to the version to be published.
- Treede RD et al (2008) Redifinition and a grading system for clinical and research purposes. Neuropathic pain. Neurology 70:1630–1635View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dieleman JP et al (2008) Incidence rates and treatment of neuropathic pain conditions in the general population. Pain 137(3):681–688View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Macrae WA (2001) Chronic pain after surgery. Br J Anaesth 87(1):88–98View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Freynhagen R, Bennett MI (2009) Diagnosis and management of neuropathic pain. BMJ 339:b3002View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Leung, L. and C.M. Cahill. TNF-alpha and neuropathic pain - a review. J. Neuroinflammation, 2010. 7(27).Google Scholar
- Hecke van, O., et al., Neuropathic pain in the general population: a systematic review of epidemiological studies. Pain, 2013.Google Scholar
- O'Connor AB (2009) Neuropathic pain: quality-of-life impact, costs and cost effectiveness of therapy. Pharmacoeconomics 27(2):95–112View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Allen S (2005) Pharmacotherapy of neuropathic pain. Contin Educ Anaesth Crit Care Pain 5(4):134–7View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Clark, A.K., E.A. Old, and M. Malcangio, Neuropathic pain and cytokines: current perspectives. Journal of pain research, 2013(6): p. 803–814.Google Scholar
- Thacker MA et al (2007) Pathophysiology of peripheral neuropathic pain: immune cells and molecules. Anesth Analg 3:838–847View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bennett GJ, Xie YK (1988) A peripheral mononeuropathy in rat that produces disorders of pain sensation like those seen in man. Pain 1:87–8107View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mogil JS (2009) Animal models of pain: progress and challenges. Nat Rev Neurosci 10:283–94View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Robinson I, Meert TF (2005) Stability of neuropathic pain symptoms in partial sciatic nerve ligation in rats is affected by suture material. Neurosci Lett 373(2):125–129View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gabay E, Tal M (2004) Pain behavior and nerve electrophysiology in the CCI model of neuropathic pain. Pain 110(1–2):354–360View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bridges D, Thompson SW, Rice AS (2001) Mechanisms of neuropathic pain. Br J Anaesth 1:12–26View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Selvig KA, Biagiotti GR, Leknes KN (1998) Oral tissue reactions to suture materials. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 18(5):474–87Google Scholar
- Vissers K, Meert T (2005) A behavioral and pharmacological validation of the acetone spray test in gerbils with a chronic constriction injury. Anesth Analg 2:457–64View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jasmin L et al (1998) The cold plate as a test of nociceptive behaviors: description and application to the study of chronic neuropathic and inflammatory pain models. Pain 75:367–382View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Field MJ et al (1999) Detection of static and dynamic components of mechanical allodynia in rat models of neuropathic pain: are they signalled by distinct primary sensory neurones? Pain 83(2):303–311View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chaplan SR et al (1994) Quantitative assessment of tactile allodynia in the rat paw. J Neurosci Methods 53:55–63View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Osikowicz M et al (2008) Glutamate receptor ligands attenuate allodynia and hyperalgesia and potentiate morphine effects in a mouse model of neuropathic pain. Pain 139(1):117–126View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dell RB, Holleran S, Ramakrishnan R (2002) Sample size determination. ILAR L 43(4):207–13View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Allchorne, A.J., D.C. Broom, and C.J. Woolf, Detection of cold pain, cold allodynia and cold hyperalgesia in freely behaving rats. Molecular Pain, 2005. 1(36).Google Scholar
- Tanimoto-Mori S et al (2008) Pharmacologic investigation of the mechanism underlying cold allodynia using a new cold plate procedure in rats with chronic constriction injuries. Behav Pharmacol 19(1):85–90View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Toyama S et al (2014) Characterization of acute and chronic neuropathies induced by oxaliplatin in mice and differential effects of a novel mitochondria-targeted antioxidant on the neuropathies. Anesthesiology 120(2):459–73View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brenner DS, Vogt SK, Gereau RW (2014) A technique to measure cold adaptation in freely behaving mice. J Neurosci Methods 236:86–91View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Andrews K (1993) The effect of changes in temperature and humidity on the accuracy of von Frey hairs. J Neurosci Methods 50:91–93View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kauppila T, Kontinen VK, Pertovaara A (1998) Weight bearing of the limb as a confounding factor in assessment of mechanical allodynia in the rat. Pain 74:55–59View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.