- Open Access
Bias problems in culture-independent analysis of environmental bacterial communities: a representative study on hydrocarbonoclastic bacteria
SpringerPlus volume 2, Article number: 369 (2013)
Culture-dependent methods for bacterial community analysis are currently considered obsolete; therefore, molecular techniques are usually used instead. The results of the current study on hydrocarbonoclastic bacteria in various oily habitats in Kuwait showed however, that the bacterial identities varied dramatically according to the analytical approach used. For six desert and six seawater samples used in this study, the culture-independent and culture-dependent techniques each led to a unique bacterial composition. Problems related to the culture-dependent technique are well known. The results of the current study highlighted bias problems other than those already recorded in the literature for the molecular approaches. Thus, for example, in contrast to the culture-dependent technique, the primers used in the molecular approach preferentially amplified the 16S rDNAs of hydrocarbonoclastic bacteria in total genomic DNAs of all the studied environmental samples, and in addition, failed to reveal in any environmental sample members of the Actinobacteria. The primers used in the molecular approach also amplified certain “pure” 16S rDNAs, but failed to do so when these DNAs were in mixture. In view of these results, it is recommended that the two analytical approaches should be used simultaneously because their combined results would reflect the bacterial community composition more precisely than either of them can do alone.
The end of the 19th century witnessed the development of the well known and long adopted culture-dependent approach which is used for the study of the structure of the bacterial communities in various environments. This approach drove advances in microbiology, in spite of its well known, serious limitations (Amann et al. 1995; Jannasch & Jones 1959), mainly related to the selectivity of the nutrient media and culture conditions which lead to favoring only a fraction of the inhabiting bacterial community. The major limitation of this classical technique is thus, that it dramatically underestimates the microbial numbers and composition in the samples under study. On the other hand, the major advantage of this approach over the modern molecular techniques lies in that it provides the researcher with the microbial “material” that can be used in further studies.
Within the past few decades, molecular approaches have been developed (Head et al. 1998; Jannasch & Jones 1959; Muyzer & Smalla 1998) and used as alternative methods, neglecting in most studies the culture-depedent techniques, which are considered by most modern microbiologists as “obsolete”. The molecular methods “provide a new insight into microbial diversity and allow a more rapid, high resolution description of microbial communities than that provided by the traditional approach of isolation of microorganisms” (Dahllöf et al. 2000). Molecular approaches which comprise among others the combination of DGGE fingerprinting with sequencing of 16S rDNA bands to identify the species present in the environmental samples (Fuhrman & Davies 1997; Nielsen et al. 1999; Rölleke et al. 1999), and correlating the banding patterns and band numbers on DGGE gels with environmental variables (El Fantroussi et al. 1999; Nübel et al. 1999; Sievert et al. 1999; van Hannen et al. 1999a; van Hannen et al. 1999b) also have their limitations. Serious artifacts (Polz & Cavanaugh 1998; Sipos et al. 2007) do arise viz preferential amplification of upcoming species, inadequate specificity of primers used for DNA amplification, production of single bands by multiple strains and others.
During two decades of research on microorganisms in pristine and oily Kuwaiti areas that were polluted via the greatest man-made oil-pollution catastrophy in association with the second Gulf War, 1990/1991 (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012), we consistently noticed that microbial identities determined by using culture-dependent methods for analysis were dramatically, sometimes completely different from those determined using molecular approaches. Here, we demonstrate this in a microbiological study on hydrocarbon-utilizing bacterial community structures in seawater and desert samples with over 20 years history of heavy oil-pollution. We concluded from the results that the simultaneous use of the traditional culture-dependent methods, along with the modern molecular techniques is a must for obtaining precise findings from such studies.
Materials and methods
Oily and pristine seawater and desert soil samples were collected from various sites (Figure 1) along the Arabian Gulf coast, and from the desert of Kuwait, and processed the same day. As the culture-dependent method, we adopted the traditional dilution-plate method using a mineral medium with oil-vapor as the sole source of carbon and energy (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012). Representative colonies of oil vapor-utilizing bacteria were isolated and purified, their total DNA’s were extracted, the 16S rRNA genes were amplified using the universal primer pair GM5F and 907R, the amplicons were sequenced and the sequences compared with the nearest GenBank sequences (method details are available in reference (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012).
For the molecular analysis of the environmental samples, the total genomic DNAs in the latter were extracted using Rapid Water DNA Isolation Kit (MO-BIO, Carlsbad, CA) for seawater samples and Fast DNA Spin for Soil Kit (MP Biomedicals, LLC., France) for desert soil samples. The extracts were stored at −80°C until used. The 16S rRNA-genes in the purified extracts were amplified as described earlier (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012). The 16S rDNA amplicons were subjected to parallel DGGE using Dcode Universal Mutation Detection System (Bio-Rad, California, USA). The denaturant concentrations were 45–55% for seawater samples and 45-60% for desert soil samples. DGGE was processed with the constant voltage of 50 V at 60°C for 16 h. Gels were stained with SYBR Green (Invitrogen, USA) in 1× TAE buffer (1:100000) for 30 min, and examined using a Dark Reader transilluminator (Clare Chemical Research, CO, USA). The bands were transformed into binary matrix; the presence of bands was given the weight of (1) and their absence (0). The binary matrix produced was analyzed using cluster analysis and dendrograms were plotted. For identification of individual bands; gel bands were excised, stored in 50 μl molecular water (Sigma, UK) at 4°C overnight to elute the DNA, 1 μl of the eluted DNA was amplified using the above primers, sequenced and the sequences were compared with the sequences in the GenBank database.
The results of the culture-dependent analysis of the oil-polluted seawater and desert soil samples for the structure of their hydrocarbon-utilizing bacterial communities have been published before (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012), and are mentioned here only for comparison with the results of the current molecular analysis. The same environmental samples were used the same sampling day for total DNA extraction; the extracts were stored at −80°C and used in the current study. Details of environmental conditions that were prevailing during sampling have been described elsewhere in details (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012).
The results of the DGGE analysis of partially amplified 16S rDNA of the studied samples are presented in Figures 2 and 3. For the purpose of comparison, we also co-analyzed nearby, visually pristine samples. The DGGE profiles of the various seawater samples (Figure 2) showed a high degree of similarity as far as the 16S rDNA band numbers and migration patterns are concerned. This similarity was also valid for the profiles of the same sample irrespective of whether it was pristine or oil-polluted. In contrast, the DGGE profiles of the desert soil samples (Figure 3) exhibited dramatic variations, also depending on whether the sample was pristine or oil-polluted.
The 16S rDNA bands in Figures 2 and 3 were amplified, sequenced and the sequences were compared with the nearest sequences in the GenBank database. Like it was the case in many of our (and other) earlier reports, we failed to sequence many of the bands excised from the DGGE-gel. The results of this analysis (Tables 1 and 2) revealed only very little similarity but dramatic differences in comparison with the results previously obtained by the culture-dependent method (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012).
The slight similarity was expressed in the predominance of the phylum Gammaproteobacteria in seawater and its relative rarity in the terrestrial samples. Assuming that each DGGE band on the gel represents one single species, as commonly accepted, our results demonstrate that the species numbers determined by using the molecular analysis for all the environmental samples were more than the numbers determined by using the culture-dependent method, and the differences were more pronounced for the desert than the seawater samples (Table 3). For the seawater samples, the differences ranged between about 1 and 4 fold, whereas for the desert samples, they ranged between about 1 and 12 fold more species counted by the molecular than by the culture-dependent methods.
In none of the six desert samples investigated could any single species be simultaneously recorded in the composition lists obtained by using the two techniques. Even the species belonging to the genera Bacillus and Acinetobacter in Ash Shua’yba and Al-Wafra samples, respectively varied according to the analytical approach. Using the culture-dependent method (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012), we recorded B. infantis and A. septicus, whereas by the molecular analysis, we recorded B. niacini, B. selenatarsenatis and A. junii. Basically, the same observation, albeit at a slightly less pronounced level, could be made for the open seawater samples. In two samples; Sharq and Az Zour the bacterial species lists were totally different depending on the analytical technique. In the other remaining seawater samples, the molecular approach revealed only two species, Alteromonas macleodii and Pseudoalteromonas phenolica, which were also recorded by the culture-dependent method (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012). The remaining species were totally different, as obvious in Table 3. The analytical technique-dependent differences of the bacterial community composition are also quite obvious in the phylogenetic trees based on the bacteria analyzed by the molecular approach in Figures 4 & 5 as compared with the corresponding trees based on bacteria analyzed by the traditional culture-deoendent method (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012).
For each of the 24 studied environmental samples, the bacterial community composition determined by using the culture-dependent method (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012) was dramatically, sometimes totally different from that determined by using the molecular approach. This implies that none of the two techniques can be used as a substitute of the other, since each of them favors bacterial taxa different from these favored by the other. Consequently, in order to limit the bias, both approaches should be adopted simultaneously, and the collective result would obviously reflect the “real bacterial composition” more precisely than that obtained using either of them alone, even though the bias problems are still not rased.
To provide a further evidence for the validity of the latter conclusion, the contribution of both techniques to the analysis of the group of the “obligate oil-degrading marine bacteria” in the seawater samples is highlighted. This is a new and ecophysiologically unusual group recently recognized and termed “the obligate hydrocarbonoclastic bacteria (OHCB)”; they repotedly play the major role in bioremediating oil in the marine ecosystem (Yakimov et al. 2007). The most common OHCB are species belonging to a few genera; Alcanivorax, Marinobacter, Thalassolituus, Cycloclasticus and Oleispira that occur in pristine seawater in minute numbers, but bloom immediately after oil-pollution. Our results show that Alcanivorax described as the “paradigm” of the OHCB (Yakimov et al. 2007), and Marinobacter were recorded, respectively, in 4 and 2 of the studied seawater sites, but only by using the culture-dependent analytical method (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012). The molecular approach we adopted failed to reveal any of the two OHCB genera in any of the six seawater samples. On the other hand, the genus Thalassolituus was recorded in all six sampling sites, but only when the molecular approach was adopted. By neither of the two techniques could Cycloclasticus and Oleispira be recorded in any of the six seawater samples. Probably, the two genera were not present in the studied samples. Interestingly however, using the molecular (but not the culture-dependent) approach, we recorded the former genus in biofilms on glass plates submerged in pristine and oily Gulf-water (Al-Bader et al. 2012).
The DGGE profile similarities of the different seawater samples (Figure 1) should be expected, in view of that seawater in situ is an “open” environment in which the whole water body becomes mechanically mixed up to some extent. Remote samples would thus, show a degree of similarity in their microbial composition. Meanwhile, the DGGE dissimilarities of the different desert soil samples (Figure 2) may be explained on the basis that the processes regulating the bacterial species frequencies in various localities, the so-called patchiness operate at a very narrow, sometimes centimeter spacial scale (Duarte & Vaqué 1992; Long & Farooq 2001; Seuront et al. 2002; Seymour et al. 2000). Expectedly, this phenomenon should be more pronounced in the “closed”, terrestrial than the “open”, aquatic environments. The observed frequent occurrence of the Gammaproteobacteria in the Arabian Gulf water body has also often been recorded by earlier investigators (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012; Al-Sarawi et al. 2008) in the marine habitats.
An important and well known advantage of the culture-dependent approach is that it routinely analyses specific groups of bacteria (in this study oil-utilizers) via the use of selective nutrient media. Since this is not the case with the molecular analysis, we had to compare our results with literature reports. The comparison confirmed that all the bacterial genera listed in Table 3, with the only exception of Sediminibacterium and Phaeobacter, comprised hydrocarbon-utilizing species (see pertinent reference numbers in Table 3). This result demonstrates a serious bias, namely that the used molecular approach preferentially amplified the 16S rDNAs of hydrocarbon-utilizing bacteria in the total DNA extracts from the environmental samples and might have “neglected” others. Still another even more pronounced bias is that the molecular approach used did not reveal in any of the studied environmental samples any member of the phylum Actinobacteria. This was true although by using the culture-dependent method, many species belonging to this phylum were found (sometimes predominant) especially in the desert soil samples (Al-Awadhi et al. 2012). Obviously the technique successfully amplifies certain 16S rDNA’s only when in pure form, but not when mixed with others, as it is the case in the environmental samples. The molecular analysis of bacterial communities on biofilms that developed on glass plates submerged in pristine and oily seawater from the Arabian Gulf (samples similar to those used in this study) also did not reveal one single species belonging to the Actinobacteria (Al-Bader et al. 2012). The present state of knowledge about this subject in the literature is too limited to explain the reason for this latter bias of preferential amplification.
It should be expected that the molecular technique would reveal in every environmental sample most, if not all of the bacterial species that showed up in these samples using the culture-dependent method. Therefore, the most surprising result in our study was that the identities of the bacteria analyzed by both techniques for all the studied samples (and for samples analyzed earlier in our laboratory) were dramatically different. In this context, the assumption that each DGGE band represents one single species is not correct (Sekiguchi et al. 2001). It is established today that differential/preferential amplification of 16S rRNA-genes in environmental samples usually leads to serious bias regarding the actual composition of the bacterial communities (Polz & Cavanaugh 1998; Sipos et al. 2007). Again the results of the current study demonstrate that the technique-dependent differences in community composition are so dramatic that both techniques should necessarily complete, and not just substitute one another in every study. This is true although both approaches are associated with own bias problems. Based on our results, the molecular approach does not seem to reveal numerically much more bacterial species (even though it reveals different rather than the same species) in the environmental samples than the culture-dependent approach, as commonly believed, so far. As shown above, the differences were in all the studied samples only between about 1 and 12 fold, in favor of the molecular approach. This may appear to contradict the well known fact that direct microscopic counts give frequently up to 104 fold more bacterial cell numbers than those counted by the culture-dependent method. This implies that the cells counted microscopically are most probably members of “strains” or “varieties” belonging to a limited number of species, rather than to different species as frequently misunderstood.
As already mentioned, modern microbiologists tend to consider the traditional culture-dependent methods obsolete and prefer the use of the modern molecular approaches instead. However, this study surprisingly showed that the two approaches revealed distinctly different bacterial communities for each studied sample. This unexpected result consolidates that both techniques must not substitute one another, but should mutually complement each other, in order to gain a bacterial composition most close to reality.
Al-Awadhi H, Al-Mailem D, Dashti N, Khanafer M, Radwan SS: Indigenous hydrocarbon-utilizing bacterioflora in oil-polluted habitats in Kuwait, two decades after the greatest man-made oil-spill. Arch Microbiol 2012, 194: 689-705. 10.1007/s00203-012-0800-7
Al-Bader D, Kansour M, Rayan R, Radwan SS: Biofilm comprising 354 phototrophic, diazotrophic, and hydrocarbon-utilizing bacteria: a promising 355 consortium in the bioremediation of aquatic hydrocarbon pollutants. Environ Sci Pollut Res (2013) 2012, 20: 3252-3262.
Al-Sarawi HA, Mahmoud HM, Radwan SS: Pyruvate-utilizing bacteria as contributors to the food web in the Arabian Gulf. Mar Biol 2008, 154: 337-381.
Amann RI, Ludwig W, Schleifer KH: Phylogenetic identification and in situ detection of individual microbial cells without cultivation. Microbiol Rev 1995, 59: 143-169.
Arun K, Ashok M, Rajesh S: Crude oil PAH constitution, degradation pathway and associated bioremediation microflora: an overview. Int J Environ Sci 2011, 1: 1420-1439.
Dahllöf I, Baillie H, Kjelleberg S: rpoB -based microbial community analysis avoids limitations inherent in 16S rRNA gene intraspecies heterogeneity. Appl Environ Microbiol 2000, 66: 3376-3380. 10.1128/AEM.66.8.3376-3380.2000
Duarte CM, Vaqué D: Scale dependence of bacterioplankton patchiness. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 1992, 84: 95-100.
El Fantroussi S, Verschuere L, Verstraete W, Top EM: Effect of phenylurea herbicides on soil microbial communities estimated by analysis of 16S rRNA gene fingerprints and community-level physiological profiles. Appl Environ Microbiol 1999, 65: 982-988.
Fuhrman JA, Davies AA: Widespread Archaea and novel Bacteria from the deep sea as shown by 16S rRNA gene sequences. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 1997, 150: 275-285.
Head IM, Saunders JR, Pickup RW: Microbial evolution, diversity, and ecology: a decade of ribosomal RNA analysis of uncultivated microorganisms. Microb Ecol 1998, 35: 1-21. 10.1007/s002489900056
Jannasch HW, Jones GE: Bacterial populations in sea water as determined by different methods of enumeration. Limnol Oceanogr 1959, 4: 128-139. 10.4319/lo.1959.4.2.0128
Jiménez N, Viñas M, Bayona JM, Albaiges J, Solanas AM: The Prestige oil spill: bacterial community dynamics during a field biostimulation assay. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 2007, 77: 935-945. 10.1007/s00253-007-1229-9
Kleinsteuber S, Riis V, Fetzer I, Harms H, Muller S: Population Dynamics within a Microbial Consortium during Growth on Diesel Fuel in Saline Environments. Appl Envir Microbiol 2006, 72: 3531-3542. 10.1128/AEM.72.5.3531-3542.2006
Larentis M, Hoermann K, Lueders T: Combined monitoring of aerobic and anaerobic contaminant degradation genes as a tool to assess NA. GOODWATER introductory winterschool, December 7–11. Helmholtz Zentrum München, (HMGU); 2009.
Long RA, Farooq A: Microscale patchiness of bacterioplankton assemblage richness in seawater. Aquat Microb Ecol 2001, 26: 103-113.
Morawski B, Eaton RW, Rossiter JT, Guoping S, Griengl H, Ribbons DW: 2-Naphthoate catabolic pathway in Burkholderia strain JT 1500. J Bacteriol 1997, 179: 115-121.
Muyzer G, Smalla K: Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) in microbial ecology. Anton Leeuw Int J 1998, 73: 127-141. 10.1023/A:1000669317571
Nielsen AT, Liu WT, Filipe C, Grady L, Molin S, Stahl DA: Identification of a novel group of bacteria in sludge from a deteriorated biological phosphorus removal reactor. Appl Environ Microbiol 1999, 65: 1251-1258.
Nübel U, Garcia-Pichel F, Kuhl M, Muyzer G: Quantifying microbial diversity: morphotypes, 16S rRNA genes, and carotenoids of oxygenic phototrophs in microbial mats. Appl Environ Microbiol 1999, 65: 422-430.
Polz MF, Cavanaugh CM: Bias in template-to-product ratios in multitemplate PCR. Appl Environ Microbiol 1998, 64: 3724-3730.
Prabagaran SR, Manorama R, Delille D, Shivaji S: Predominance of Roseobacter , Sulfitobacter , Glaciecola and Psychrobacter in seawater collected off Ushuaia, Argentina, sub-Antarctica. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 2007, 59: 342-355.
Rölleke SS, Gurtner C, Drewello U, Drewello R, Lubitz W, Weissmann R: Analysis of bacterial communities on historical glass by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of PCR-amplified gene fragments coding for 16S rRNA. J Microbiol Methods 1999, 36: 107-114. 10.1016/S0167-7012(99)00015-9
Scherr KE, Lundaa T, Klose V, Bochmann G, Loibner AP: Changes in bacterial communities from anaerobic digesters during petroleum hydrocarbon degradation. J Biotechnol 2012, 157: 564-572. 10.1016/j.jbiotec.2011.09.003
Sekiguchi H, Tomioka N, Nakahara T, Uchiyama H: A single band does not always represent single bacterial strains in denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis. Biotechnol Lett 2001, 23: 1205-1208. 10.1023/A:1010517117046
Seuront L, Gentilhomme V, Lagadeuc Y: Small-scale nutrient patches in tidally mixed coastal waters. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 2002, 232: 29-44.
Seymour JR, Mitchell JG, Pearson L, Waters RL: Heterogeneity in bacterioplankton abundance from 4.5 millimetre resolution sampling. Aquat Microb Ecol 2000, 22: 143-153.
Sievert S, Brinkhoff T, Muyzer G, Ziebis W, Kuever J: Spatial heterogeneity of bacterial populations along an environmental gradient at a shallow submarine hydrothermal vent near Milos Island (Greece). Appl Environ Microbiol 1999, 65: 3834-3842.
Sipos R, Székely AJ, Palatinsky M, Révész S, Marialigeti K, Nikolausz M: Effect of primer mismatch, annealing temperature and PCR cycle number on 16S rRNA gene-targetting bacterial community analysis. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 2007, 60: 341-350. 10.1111/j.1574-6941.2007.00283.x
Teramoto M, Suzuki M, Okazaki F, Hatmanti A, Harayama S: Oceanobacter -related bacteria are important for the degradation of petroleum aliphatic hydrocarbons in the tropical marine environment. Microbiol 2009, 155: 3362-3370. 10.1099/mic.0.030411-0
van Hannen EJ, Mooij W, van Agterveld MP, Gons HJ, Laanbroek HJ: Detritus-dependent development of the microbial community in an experimental system: qualitative analysis by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Appl Environ Microbiol 1999a, 65: 2478-2484.
van Hannen EJ, Zwart G, van Agterveld MP, Gons HJ, Ebert J, Laanbroek HJ: Changes in bacterial and eukaryotic community structure after mass lysis of filamentous cyanobacteria associated with viruses. Appl Environ Microbiol 1999b, 65: 795-801.
Wan C, Du M, Lee DJ, Yang X, Ma W, Zheng L: Electrokinetic remediation and microbial community shift of β-cyclodextrin-dissolved petroleum hydrocarbon-contaminated soil. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 2011, 89: 2019-2025. 10.1007/s00253-010-2952-1
Wang YN, Cai H, Yu SL, Wang ZY, Liu J, Wu XL: Halomonas gudaonensis sp. nov., isolated from a saline soil contaminated by crude oil. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 2007, 57: 911-915. 10.1099/ijs.0.64826-0
Yakimov MM, Giuliano L, Denaro R, Crisafi E, Chernikova TN, Abraham WR, Luensdorf H, Timmis KN, Golyshin PN: Thalassolituus oleivorans gen. nov., sp nov., a novel marine bacterium that obligately utilizes hydrocarbons. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 2004, 54: 141-148. 10.1099/ijs.0.02424-0
Yakimov MM, Timmis KN, Golyshin PN: Obligate oil-degrading marine bacteria. Curr Opin Biotech 2007, 18: 257-266. 10.1016/j.copbio.2007.04.006
Yergeau E, Lawrence JR, Sanschagrin S, Waiser MJ, Korber DR, Greer CW: 458 Next-generation sequencing of microbial communities in the Athabasca 459 River and its tributaries in relation to oil sands mining activities. Appl Environ Microbiol (2012) 2012, 78: 7626-7637. 10.1128/AEM.02036-12
Zhu H, Singleton DR, Aitken MD: Effects of nonionic surfactant addition on populations of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon-degrading bacteria in a bioreactor treating contaminated soil. Environ Sci Technol 2010, 44: 7266-7271. 10.1021/es100114g
This study has been supported by Kuwait University, research grant SL01/08.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
HA, MK, DM participated in sample collection and DGGE analysis. ND, NA, MK, SR contributed to molecular analysis. SR suggested the research problem and finalized the manuscript. All authors read and approved the manuscript.