- Open Access
Presence of bacteria in failed anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions
SpringerPlus volume 4, Article number: 460 (2015)
Novel microbial detection technologies have revealed that chronic bacterial biofilms, which are recalcitrant to antibiotic treatment, are common in failed orthopedic procedures.
Are bacteria present on failed anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructions? Is there a difference in the presence or nature of bacteria in failed ACL reconstructions relative to a control set of healthy ACL’s?
We used a case–control study design, where we analyzed the bacterial composition of 10 failed ACL reconstructions and compared it to 10 native ACL’s harvested during total knee arthroplasty. The IBIS Universal Biosensor was used to determine the nature of bacteria on ACL specimens, and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to visualize bacteria in a subset of cases.
Bacteria are present in failed ACL reconstructions. Bacteria are present in ACL’s harvested during total knee arthroplasty, but the nature of the species differs significantly between experimental and control sets. Twelve genera were detected in the experimental set (in both allografts and autografts), and in four samples multiple species were detected. In contrast, the control group was characterized by presence of Propionibacterium acnes.
We demonstrate the presence of bacteria on failed ACLs surgeries, and open the door to investigate whether and how bacteria and the associated immune responses could possibly contribute to graft failure.
If microbial pathogens can be linked to failed grafts, it could provide: (1) markers for early diagnosis of abnormal healing in ACL surgeries, and (2) targets for early treatment to prevent additional reconstruction surgeries.
Revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery is a challenging problem for orthopaedic surgeons and their patients as long-term outcomes of revision ACL surgery have been shown to be inferior to primary ACL reconstructions (Wright et al. 2012). Failed primary ACL reconstructions can be attributed to traumatic rupture of the graft, technical error, failure of the graft to incorporate, biologic factors, or a combination of the above (MARS Group et al. 2010). When using standard culture to detect infections, revision ACL surgery secondary to infection is reported in less than 1 % of all primary ACL reconstructions (Barker et al. 2010; Burks et al. 2003; Hettrich et al. 2013; Indelli et al. 2002; Katz et al. 2008; Matava et al. 1998; McAllister et al. 1999; Williams et al. 1997); diabetes is a major risk factor associated with post-operative infection (Brophy et al. 2015). When present, deep infection can hinder the ability of the graft to incorporate into the femoral or tibial tunnels, or weaken the structure of the fibers of the graft. A combination of mechanical and biologic factors can cause tunnel lysis or enlargement which leads to long-term instability of the graft (Wilson et al. 2004). Some studies did not observe a significant difference in the rate of infection between allografts and autografts, (Burks et al. 2003; Katz et al. 2008), while a large (>2000) patient cohort noted an association between lower rate of infection and autografts (Brophy et al. 2015).
The rate of infections in orthopedic infections has been severely underestimated since clinical infections are usually detected by microbial cultures (Costerton et al. 2011). Studies on culture-negative revision arthroplasties, osteomyelitis, and bone fractures often reveal bacterial DNA and/or direct visualization of bacteria by microscopy (Costerton et al. 2005; Floyed and Steele 2003; Palmer et al. 2014; Tunney et al. 1998) (Gallo et al. 2011; Stoodley et al. 2008). This discrepancy is a result of the differences in metabolism between non-adherent planktonic bacteria and the slime-enclosed communities (termed biofilms) characteristic of chronic infections, which are resistant to growth on agar medium. Bacteria growing in chronic biofilms often do not invade host tissues or release toxins, and consequently can remain undetected for months or years (Costerton et al. 2007). An infectious etiology behind failed ACL reconstruction that has not been evaluated specifically is the presence of bacteria on reconstructed ACL grafts and their potential long-term effects.
In this study we applied the Ibis Universal Biosensor, which integrates polymerase chain reactions (PCR) and mass spectroscopy (MS) to detect and characterize bacteria on failed ACL grafts and compared them to native ACL’s harvested during total knee arthroplasty. In a subset of cases the bacteria was visualized by confocal microscopy using fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) with probes targeted at species-specific regions of the 16S rRNA gene. The goal of this study was to test the hypothesis that bacteria are present on failed ACL grafts, and that the bacterial species differ between failed ACL grafts and native ACL’s harvested during total knee arthroplasty.
Description of subjects and detection technology
The experimental group was composed of 4 males and 6 females with a mean age of 30 years old undergoing revision surgery for failed primary ACL reconstruction. The primary grafts were three allografts and seven autografts. The control group was composed of 6 males and 4 females with a mean age of 68 years old undergoing a primary total knee arthroplasty. The material analyzed consisted of tissue, aspirate and/or synovial fluid obtained intra-operatively. Arthroscopic evaluation during revision ACL reconstruction and direct clinical analysis during the total knee arthroplasties did not reveal signs of clinical infection at the time of surgery (Table 1).
Microbial detection was performed on the PCR-MS platform using the BAC detection plate. This analysis does not require prior knowledge of bacterial presence and is independent of traditional culture. The PCR primers are targeted at the universally conserved 16s rRNA gene and are optimized to classify the most abundant species within the samples. The BAC detection plate is extremely sensitive to Staphylococci since it contains additional primers targeting at this genus. Furthermore, primers targeted at the 23S rRNA gene will capture Candida sp and Saccharomyces sp, which were not detected in this study suggesting the ACLs were not infected with these fungal species.
Microbial composition of ACLs
The PCR-MS identified bacteria in both the experimental and control samples, but the nature of the bacteria detected differed significantly between the sets (Fig. 1). Eighty percent of ACLs from failed grafts (including both the autografts and allografts) demonstrated evidence of bacterial DNA: Staphylococci (4/10), Streptococci (3/10), Clostridium (2/10), Propionibacterium acnes (2/10) and Treponema denticola (2/10), as well as single cases of Acinetobacter, Enterococcus faecalis, Escherichia coli, Lactobacillus crispatus, Nocardia asteroides, Pseudomonas mendocina, and Shigella flexneri. In contrast, the control group was characterized by presence of Propionibacterium acnes (8/10). Four experimental patients showed evidence of multiple species: one patient with N. asteroides, P. acne, and S. epidermitis; a second with Lactobacillus crispatus and T. denticola; a third with Clostridium, Enterococcus faecalis, Escherichia coli, T. denticola and S. epidermitis; and a fourth with Acinetobacter, Clostrium, Propibacteirum acnes, Pseudomonas mendocina, Staphylococcus hominis, and Streptococcus sp (Fig. 1). Eighty percent of the control group demonstrated evidence of bacterial DNA, but in this set the defining species was Propionibacterium acnes (8/10). In one control patient Acinetobacter and Sneathia were also detected. The gene coding for methicillin resistance was encountered in two patients from the revision ACL group.
In four experimental samples and one control sample, where sufficient tissue was available, a secondary method of analysis was applied. These samples were stained by FISH and visualized by confocal microscopy (Fig. 2). Probes were selected based on the species detected by the PCR-MS analysis specifically: Staphylococcus sp, Streptococcus sp., Lactobacillus sp and P. acnes. These probes bind 16S rRNA, thus the stained bacteria was metabolically active at the time of fixation and washing. We do not demonstrate a causal link between bacterial presence and ACL failure. However, the presence of bacteria in these failed ACL supports further investigations to determine whether there is a role for bacteria in tissue degeneration and/or host inflammation.
The overall ACL revision rate varies in the literature, with the most recent longitudinal long-term results from the MOON group reporting an overall 7.7 % revision rate of the ACL reconstructed knee at 6 years follow-up (Hettrich et al. 2013). Management of septic arthritis following ACL reconstruction requires immediate arthroscopic irrigation and debridement. The rate of removal and replantation of the graft varies in the literature, with recent evidence to suggest that immediate irrigation and debridement with retention of the graft may lead to acceptable results at 5 years of follow-up (Windhamre et al. 2014; Burks et al. 2003; Maletis et al. 2013; McAllister et al. 1999; Schulz et al. 2007; Williams et al. 1997).
Currently infections are monitored using standard culture techniques, and are reported in less than 1 % of ACL reconstructions (Barker et al. 2010; Burks et al. 2003; Hettrich et al. 2013; Indelli et al. 2002; Katz et al. 2008; Matava et al. 1998; McAllister et al. 1999; Williams et al. 1997). Our PCR-MS analysis detected bacteria in eighty percent of the experimental samples, suggesting that bacterial presence is ACLs is significantly underestimated by current techniques. This is consistent with studies on other types of orthopedic infections where bacteria were present in culture-negative orthopedic infections (Costerton et al. 2011; Jacovides et al. 2012; Palmer et al. 2014; Stoodley et al. 2011a, b; Mariscalco et al. 2014).
The most common culture positive pathogens associated with septic arthritis after ACL reconstruction are S. epidermis and S. aureus (Barker et al. 2010; Burks et al. 2003; Hettrich et al. 2013; Indelli et al. 2002; Katz et al. 2008; Matava et al. 1998; McAllister et al. 1999; Williams et al. 1997; Windhamre et al. 2014; Maletis et al. 2013). We detected these species in 3/10 of the experimental set and none of the control set. The bacterial species identified in the experimental sample are common human flora, and have been associated with both commensal and pathogenic states. Multiple genera identified in the experimental set have been identified in other types of orthopedic infections including Staphylococci, Streptococci, and Treponema. These three genera are oral colonizers, thus it is possible that these oral bacteria gain access to the circulation and establish a local infection when they encounter damaged tissue. The route of entry and its clinical significance remain open to debate and should be addressed in future studies.
While bacteria were detected in both experimental and control groups, the species composition varied between these groups. Multiple species of known human pathogens were encountered in the failed grafts. In contrast, arthroplasty samples were characterized by the presence of P. acnes—a common skin commensal. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the activation of either bacterial regulatory pathways and/or host inflammatory responses affects the healing of ligaments and bone that are required in the repair of ACL damage. Alternatively, it is possible that these bacteria are present but do not play a role in graft failure. The present of P. acnes in the control samples from knee arthoplasties underscores the importance of characterizing the specific species and suggests that presence of bacteria alone does not implicate ACL damage. In fact, it is possible that under some conditions certain bacterial species could be beneficial by competing away pathogens or modulating inflammation. The correlation between individual species, host response, and damage is an import next step.
Failed ACL reconstructions can be attributed to many causes and our study shows that bacteria are commonly present within reconstructed ACL grafts irrespective of the type of graft used. A chronic, indolent bacterial infection could contribute to a significant weakening of the graft and create a chronic inflammatory environment, which could cause further compromise to the grafts integrity. This hypothesis will require a future study to analyze the cause and effect of chronic bacterial infections on the structural integrity of the ACL graft over time. Our belief is that bacterial presence contributes to failure of ACL reconstructions, which are likely the result of many contributing factors (e.g. mechanic and biologic). If subclinical chronic bacterial infections play a role in ACL graft failure, it will open the door for the development of diagnostics and treatments, targeted at the bacteria or host inflammatory response, to prevent ACL graft failure in the future.
Study design and sample preparation
Subjects for this study were recruited at the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery at Allegheny General Hospital, and approved by the Institutional Review Board (approval number FWA00015120). A total of twenty ACLs were collected from 20 patients. The experimental group consisted of ten ACL’s from ten patients undergoing revision surgery for failed primary ACL reconstructions. The control group consisted of ten native ACL’s from ten patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty without any prior surgery. The average time to revision surgery was 7 years.
Specimens were collected under sterile conditions in the operating room, placed immediately into a RNA stabilization agent (RNAlater, Qiagen, Germantown, MD) and stored at −80 °C for evaluation with the IBIS T5000 Universal Biosensor System and/or FISH analysis.
DNA extraction and IBIS universal biosensor bacteria, antibiotic resistance, and Candida (BAC) detection assay for microbial identification
For DNA extraction the ACL was placed into a sterile microcentrifuge tube containing ATL Lysis buffer (Qiagen, Germantown, MD, cat# 19076) and proteinase K (Qiagen, cat# 19131). Samples were incubated at 56 °C until lysis. 100 μl of a mixture containing 50 μl each of 0.1 and 0.7 mm Zirconia beads (Biospec cat# 11079101z, 11079107zx respectively) were added to the samples which were then homogenized for 10 min at 25 Hz using a Qiagen Tissuelyser. Nucleic acid from the lysed sample was then extracted using the Qiagen DNeasy Tissue kit (Qiagen cat# 69506).
For microbial detection, 10 μl of each sample was loaded per well onto the BAC detection PCR plate (Abbott Molecular, cat# PN 05N13-01). The BAC detection plate is a 96 well plate which contains 16 primers that survey all bacterial organisms by using the omnipresent loci (e.g. 16S rRNA gene sequence), while some are targeted to specific pathogens of interest (e.g. the Staphylococcus-specific tufB gene). The plate also includes primers for the detection of Candida species and some antibiotic resistance markers (e.g. mecA, vanA, vanB, and KPC). An internal calibrant of synthetic nucleic acid template is also included in each assay, controlling for false negatives (e.g. from PCR inhibitors) and enabling a semi-quantitative analysis of the amount of template DNA present. PCR amplification was carried out and the products were desalted in a 96-well plate format and sequentially electrosprayed into a mass spectrometer. The spectral signals were processed to determine the identities of the pathogens and a semi-quantitative determination of their relative concentrations on the ACLs (Ecker et al. 2008).
Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH)
Aliquots of the ACL samples were fixed with fresh 4 % paraformaldehyde and incubate for 2–4 h at 4 °C. After the incubation the specimen was spun down and the supernatant removed, this process was repeated twice with Hank’s Salt Saline Solution (HBSS). Next, the samples were resuspended in 50 % Ethanol-PBS solution and stored at −20 °C for evaluation with FISH. FISH was performed as described by Nistico et al. (Nistico et al. 2014), using species-specific and genus-specific fluorescent 16 s rRNA probes. The bacteria targeted and probe sequences selected were: (1) Streptococcus “GTG ATG CAA GTG CAC CTT” (Kempf et al. 2000); (2) Staphylococcus sp “TCC TCC ATA TCT CTG CGC” (Trebesius et al. 2000); and (3) Lactobacillus sp “CCATTGTGGAAGATTCCCT” (Quevedo et al. 2011).
Samples were observed with Confocal Scanning Laser Microscopy (CSLM) imaging using a Leica DM RXE microscope attached to a TCS SP2 AOBS confocal system (Leica Microsystems, Exton, PA) using a 63X (NA1.2) water immersion lens.
Barker JU, Drakos MC, Maak TG, Warren RF, Williams RJ, Allen AA (2010) Effect of graft selection on the incidence of postoperative infection in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med 38:281–286
Brophy RH, Wright RW, Huston LJ, Nwosu SK, Group the MK, Spindler KP (2015) Factors associated with infection following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. J Bone Jt Surg 97:450–454
Burks RT, Friederichs MG, Fink B, Luker MG, West HS, Greis PE (2003) Treatment of postoperative anterior cruciate ligament infections with graft removal and early reimplantation. Am J Sports Med 31:414–418
Costerton JW, Montanaro L, Arciola CR (2005) Biofilm in implant infections: its production and regulation. Int J Artif Organs 28:1062–1068
Costerton JW, Montanaro L, Arciola CR (2007) Bacterial communications in implant infections: a target for an intelligence war. Int J Artif Organs 30:757–763
Costerton JW, Post JC, Ehrlich GD, Hu FZ, Kreft R, Nistico L et al (2011) New methods for the detection of orthopedic and other biofilm infections. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol 61:133–140
Ecker DJ, Sampath R, Massire C, Blyn LB, Hall TA, Eshoo MW et al (2008) Ibis T5000: a universal biosensor approach for microbiology. Nat Rev Microbiol 6:553–558
Floyed RL, Steele RW (2003) Culture-negative osteomyelitis. Pediatr Infect Dis J 22:731–736
Gallo PH, Melton-Kreft R, Nistico L, Sotereanos NG, Sewecke JJ, Stoodley P et al (2011) Demonstration of Bacillus cereus in orthopaedic-implant-related infection with use of a multi-primer polymerase chain reaction-mass spectrometric assay: report of two cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am 93:e85
Hettrich CM, Dunn WR, Reinke EK, MOON Group, Spindler KP (2013) The rate of subsequent surgery and predictors after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: two- and 6-year follow-up results from a multicenter cohort. Am J Sports Med 41:1534–1540
Indelli PF, Dillingham M, Fanton G, Schurman DJ (2002) Septic arthritis in postoperative anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Clin Orthop Relat Res 398:182–188
Jacovides CL, Kreft R, Adeli B, Hozack B, Ehrlich GD, Parvizi J (2012) Successful identification of pathogens by polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based electron spray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (ESI-TOF-MS) in culture-negative periprosthetic joint infection. J Bone Joint Surg Am 94:2247–2254
Katz LM, Battaglia TC, Patino P, Reichmann W, Hunter DJ, Richmond JC (2008) A retrospective comparison of the incidence of bacterial infection following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with autograft versus allograft. Arthrosc J Arthrosc Relat Surg Off Publ Arthrosc Assoc N Am Int Arthrosc Assoc 24:1330–1335
Kempf VA, Trebesius K, Autenrieth IB (2000) Fluorescent In situ hybridization allows rapid identification of microorganisms in blood cultures. J Clin Microbiol 38:830–838
Maletis GB, Inacio MCS, Reynolds S, Desmond JL, Maletis MM, Funahashi TT (2013) Incidence of postoperative anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction infections: graft choice makes a difference. Am J Sports Med 41:1780–1785
Mariscalco MW, Magnussen RA, Mehta D, Hewett TE, Flanigan DC, Kaeding CC (2014) Autograft versus nonirradiated allograft tissue for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review. Am J Sports Med 42:492–499
MARS Group, Wright RW, Huston LJ, Spindler KP, Dunn WR, Haas AK et al (2010) Descriptive epidemiology of the multicenter ACL revision study (MARS) cohort. Am J Sports Med 38:1979–1986
Matava MJ, Evans TA, Wright RW, Shively RA (1998) Septic arthritis of the knee following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: results of a survey of sports medicine fellowship directors. Arthrosc J Arthrosc Relat Surg Off Pub Arthrosc Assoc N Am Int Arthrosc Assoc 14:717–725
McAllister DR, Parker RD, Cooper AE, Recht MP, Abate J (1999) Outcomes of postoperative septic arthritis after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med 27:562–570
Nistico L, Hall-Stoodley L, Stoodley P (2014) Imaging bacteria and biofilms on hardware and periprosthetic tissue in orthopedic infections. Methods Mol Biol. Clifton NJ. 1147:105–126
Palmer MP, Altman DT, Altman GT, Sewecke JJ, Ehrlich GD, Hu FZ et al (2014) Can we trust intraoperative culture results in nonunions? J Orthop Trauma 28:384–390
Quevedo B, Giertsen E, Zijnge V, Lüthi-Schaller H, Guggenheim B, Thurnheer T, Gmür R (2011) Phylogenetic group- and species-specific oligonucleotide probes for single-cell detection of lactic acid bacteria in oral biofilms. BMC Microbiol 11:14
Schulz AP, Götze S, Schmidt HGK, Jürgens C, Faschingbauer M (2007) Septic arthritis of the knee after anterior cruciate ligament surgery: a stage-adapted treatment regimen. Am J Sports Med 35:1064–1069
Stoodley P, Nistico L, Johnson S, Lasko L-A, Baratz M, Gahlot V et al (2008) Direct demonstration of viable Staphylococcus aureus biofilms in an infected total joint arthroplasty. A case report. J Bone Joint Surg Am 90:1751–1758
Stoodley P, Conti SF, DeMeo PJ, Nistico L, Melton-Kreft R, Johnson S et al (2011a) Characterization of a mixed MRSA/MRSE biofilm in an explanted total ankle arthroplasty. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol 62:66–74
Stoodley P, Ehrlich GD, Sedghizadeh PP, Hall-Stoodley L, Baratz ME, Altman DT et al (2011b) Orthopaedic biofilm infections. Curr Orthop Pract 22:558–563
Trebesius K, Leitritz L, Adler K, Schubert S, Autenrieth IB, Heesemann J (2000) Culture independent and rapid identification of bacterial pathogens in necrotising fasciitis and streptococcal toxic shock syndrome by fluorescence in situ hybridisation. Med Microbiol Immunol Berl 188:169–175
Tunney MM, Ramage G, Patrick S, Nixon JR, Murphy PG, Gorman SP (1998) Antimicrobial susceptibility of bacteria isolated from orthopedic implants following revision hip surgery. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 42:3002–3005
Williams RJ, Laurencin CT, Warren RF, Speciale AC, Brause BD, O’Brien S (1997) Septic arthritis after arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Diagnosis and management. Am J Sports Med 25:261–267
Wilson TC, Kantaras A, Atay A, Johnson DL (2004) Tunnel enlargement after anterior cruciate ligament surgery. Am J Sports Med 32:543–549
Windhamre HB, Mikkelsen C, Forssblad M, Willberg L (2014) Postoperative septic arthritis after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: does it affect the outcome? A retrospective controlled study. Arthrosc J. Arthrosc Relat Surg Off Publ Arthrosc Assoc N Am Int Arthrosc Assoc 30:1100–1109
Wright RW, Gill CS, Chen L, Brophy RH, Matava MJ, Smith MV et al (2012) Outcome of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review. J Bone Joint Surg Am 94:531–536
Conceived and designed the experiments: PJD; performed the experiments: RK, LN, NGS, GTA; analyzed the data: NLH, PJD, JCP, AC, MP; contributed materials/analysis tools: GTA, NGS, SJ, MP; wrote the paper: NLH, PJD, JCP, RK, LN, AC, MP. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors would like to thank Angela Finamore for coordinating this study, Tracy Spirk for her work with DNA extractions, Barbara Byers and Kaitlyn DeMeo for their work with confocal imaging, and Leon Hak-Jin Kim for his work on data analysis and presentation. We are also grateful to the generous financial support from the Allegheny Health Network.
Compliance with ethical guidelines
Competing interests NLH, LN, and RK receive financial support from Allegheny Health Network. NLH is funded by the NIH Grants R00DC011322. No conflicts of interest to disclose.
Ethical review committee statement IRB approval letter is attached. Patient samples were collected at the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Allegheny General Hospital, Pittsburgh, PA, and all subjects gave their consent to participate in this study. Samples were analyzed at the Center for Excellence in Biofilm Research, Allegheny Singer Institute, Allegheny General Hospital, Pittsburgh, PA.
About this article
Cite this article
Hiller, N.L., Chauhan, A., Palmer, M. et al. Presence of bacteria in failed anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions. SpringerPlus 4, 460 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40064-015-1213-2
- Anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions
- Bacterial composition
- IBIS Universal Biosensor
- Broad-range PCR and high performance mass spectrometry