A randomized controlled trial to evaluate an educational strategy involving community health volunteers in improving self-care in patients with chronic heart failure: Rationale, design and methodology
© Siabani et al.; licensee Springer. 2014
Received: 2 August 2014
Accepted: 14 November 2014
Published: 25 November 2014
Chronic heart failure (CHF) is an increasingly important health problem worldwide. Effective self-care can improve the outcomes and quality of life in patients with CHF. Acknowledging the important role of educational interventions for improving self-care, we sought to assess a new educational strategy involving community health volunteers (CHVs) that could reduce the cost and, hypothetically, increase the effectiveness of self-care education in patients with CHF.
In this ongoing three-arm controlled trial, approved by two human research ethics committees in Australia and Iran, 231 patients with CHF registered at a referral cardiovascular hospital in Iran were randomly allocated into three groups -trained by community health volunteers at patients’ homes, rained by formal health professionals at hospital; and a control group with no formal educational exposure. Data obtained through interviewing participants and using the Persian self-care of CHF index (pSCHFI) before and two months after interventions will be analysed using SAS and SPSS.
The results of this study may help health service systems, especially in countries with limited resources, make use of community volunteers to teach patients with CHF to develop self-care behaviors and skills, reducing the cost of care and improving CHF outcomes. Also, this home-based educational strategy using face-to-face training, if successful, may provide psychosocial supports for patients suffering from chronic illnesses.
Trial registration number
ACTRN12614000788673 (Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry)
Chronic heart failure (CHF) is an increasingly important health problem with a high mortality rate and morbidity worldwide (Go et al.2013). Patients suffering from CHF often have a low quality of life (Pinto et al.2011), and the majority of patients die within five years of diagnosis (Norton et al.2011). For example, approximately 1.1 million hospitalizations for CHF cost $29 billion in 2004 in the United States (Go et al.2013), increasing to $40 billion in 2010 and similarly in European countries (Braunschweig et al.2011). Almost 70% of the expenditure is for hospital services (Heidenreich et al.2011). Effective self-care behaviors can increase quality of life in patients with CHF and reduce hospitalization (Moser et al.2012).
Self-care in CHF refers to a naturalistic decision-making process including the choice of behaviours and activities that patients use to maintain life, health and well-being. It includes a healthy lifestyle (e.g. daily exercise), adherence to a treatment regimen, symptom monitoring and seeking assistance when symptoms occur or change (Riegel et al.2009). Evidence has underscored the importance of knowledge and self-care skills in order to accomplish effective self-care in patients with CHF (van der Wal et al.2006; Siabani et al.2013). Health literacy accelerates self-care confidence (Dennison et al.2011), while lack of knowledge and self-care skills is serious obstacles for patients with CHF and their adherence to treatment (Siabani et al.2013).
During the past decade many studies have tried and assessed innovative technologies and advanced educational methods to enhance knowledge and self-care skills in patients with CHF (Baker et al.2011; Barnason et al.2012; Boyde et al.2013; Boyde et al.2011). However, these methods often prove to be ineffective. In addition, almost all interventions have been tried in developed countries rather than in populations living in countries with limited resources. Further, the technology used in these strategies (telehealth etc.) is not available in most less-developed countries. Professional-led programs, as most of these are, require resources that developing countries cannot afford (De Geest et al.2004). Therefore, educational programs using simple language, minimal technology and taught by dedicated non-professionals is theoretically a more feasible option. Community health workers’ help is a common phenomenon, especially in low- or middle- income countries mainly in the primary care setting (Maes2010; Hadi2003; Sirilak et al.2013; Giugliani et al.2011).
In Iran, in the past three decades, a new integrated health system has been introduced. It aims to address the Iranian population health needs, especially in rural area and underprivileged urban areas (Asaei2014; Malekafzali2006). Obtaining benefit from the help of community health volunteers (CHVs) locally called "Rabetin Behdasht" is a part of this system. CHVs are mostly females with basic education – high school or beyond – interested in helping the community health services without pay. The most important role of CHVs in Iran has been building a bridge between people who need follow-up (e.g. vaccination) and health delivery systems. Each CHV covers around 50–100 families living in her neighbourhood. The CHVs are trained after joining the health delivery system and asked to attend once a month at their local health centres to be given the cases for follow up. Evidence showed important progress in improving health indicators such as infant mortality rate across the country following their deployment (Asaei2014).
To date, CHVs have limited their function to family planning programs and primary prevention (Giugliani et al.2011; Malekafzali2006). Recognizing the possibility of role of educational interventions improving self-care in Iranian patients, and the limitation of resources available for this purpose we set out to assess an innovative educational strategy involving CHVs that might reduce cost and, hypothetically, increase effectiveness in improving self-care in patients with CHF.
Aim and objectives
The aim of this study is to assess the effectiveness of a new educational strategy using CHVs (strategy I) in improving self-care in patients with CHF, in comparison with a formal educational strategy (strategy II) and a control group receiving standard care. The study hypothesis is that CHVs are equally or more effective as professional health educators in educating patients with chronic heart failure to improve self-care skills.
To determine baseline self-care (self-care maintenance, self-care management and self-care confidence) in patients with CHF discharged from Imam Ali hospital (Iran) from August 2010 to June 2012.
To measure the scores relating to self-care (self-care maintenance, self-care management and self-care confidence) in each of the three arms of the study, two months after applying interventions.
To compare self-care maintenance, self-care management and self-care confidence among groups I and, II, I and III, II and III.
To explore the personal characteristics such as age and gender of study subjects.
To explore the health-related factors such as duration of CHF, number of admissions for CHF, and comorbidities (e.g. diabetes) in study subjects.
To determine the association between each personal factor (e.g. education and age) that might influence the efficacy of interventional strategies.
This study is an ongoing three-arm randomised controlled trial aiming to compare a new educational strategy involving community health volunteers (CHVs) with health-professional-based educational strategy, and a control group received standard care without educational intervention. Self-care skill scales will be assessed and compared in three groups of patients with heart failure.
Participants and setting
Two hundred thirty one patients above 18 years of age, who had been admitted to hospital at least once with CHF during last two years, but not in last two months, were recruited to participate in the study. Those who had CHF of New York Heart Association Class (NYHA) functional class II or III, and did not have cognitive problem were eligible for inclusion in this study. NYHA class IV was excluded because we excluded people with any severe mental or physical disability preventing people of self-care activities. Also, we excluded patients in class I, due to being asymptomatic, though we have not been collecting the functional status as a variable in our data collection. They were from a population of whom more than 99% are Muslim. Languages spoken in this population are Kurdish and Persian. Almost all were Caucasian and have similar cultural behaviors. Participants who met the inclusion criteria were identified in advance, using the hospitalization records, by an experienced nurse with access to the records. Subjects needed valid contact details to be included. Prior permission was obtained from the director of Imam Ali Hospital, Kermanshah, Iran. Ethics approval for the study was granted by human research ethics committees in Iran (Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences Research Ethics Committee) and Australia (University of Sydney Human Research Ethics Committee); A written informed consent for participation in the study was obtained from all participants.
The intervention included two different educational approaches to training self-care information to patients diagnosed with CHF. One group was trained face-to-face at their homes by CHVs and the second group was trained by a skilled nurse and a general practitioner in three small groups at a conference room in the hospital (Imam Ali Hospital).
Prior to the intervention ten female CHVs, aged from 27 to 53 years were trained in three workshops by a general practitioner. These subjects were selected from among fifty CHVs connected to a health delivery center (Sameno-al-aemaeh) in Kermanshah. The inclusion criteria were; an acceptable level of conversation skills, ability to speak in Persian and Kurdish, having been actively involved during the preceding year in assisting at the health center and having graduated from high school or beyond. Three one-day workshops were held to train and prepare the selected CHVs, the number and duration of workshops being based on a needs-assessment conducted at the introductory session and using the feedback from participants (CHVs) after that session.
The aim of workshops was to teach the CHVs about the content of the educational programs for patients and how to present the information. The materials were obtained from heart failure text books (Bonow et al.2011) and related sites (Krum et al.2011) that have been translated into simple Persian language understandable for patients, even those who might be illiterate. The preparation and simplification was conducted under supervision of a cardiologist. The information was provided in a PowerPoint presentation and in a notebook used in workshops. In addition, during workshops, tutors considered the likely questions or challenging issues that might be faced during their home visits. At the end of the workshops, using role play, each of CHVs was assessed to evaluate her ability as an educator. One of CHVs who did not have an acceptable result was removed from the list. Further, CHVs were given a contact number of a trained general practitioner to ask questions during home visits.
For the second group a nurse and general practitioner both experienced and working in cardiovascular disease and cardiovascular rehabilitation were employed. They were asked to study the notebook prepared as above. They were asked to educate participants, using their own knowledge and considering the aims and objectives of education. They were blind to the study purpose.
The interventions were started in parallel, though educating by CHVs lasted about two weeks because each CHV had to educate approximately seven to eight patients one-by-one and at their homes. The patients in second group –educated at hospital– were offered reimbursement for travel costs but none asked. Fees were paid to educators of this group, namely, the nurse and general practitioner. CHVs making home visits were reimbursed for travel costs. Taxi fares were paid for one of the investigators who monitored the home-based education. Two months later participants in the three groups were interviewed again at home or hospital, according to their preferences.
The self-care components including self-care maintenance, self-care management and self-care confidence would be the main outcome variables of the study. These outcomes will be assessed before intervention and two months after intervention. The Persian version of the self-care chronic heart failure index V 6.2 (pSCHFI) scales is used to evaluate self-care components in three groups of study. The SCHFI uses a quantitative, ordinal, self-report and performance-rating scale (Riegel et al.2009). Both SCHFI and pSCHFI include three scales with 22 questions–10 questions for self-maintenance, six for self-management and six for self-confidence. Each sub-scale is standardized to a possible score of zero to 100. In Persian version of SCHFI, in comparison with the original SCHFI, some grammatical changes had been made and a few words had been deleted or added, however none of those modifications did not change the meaning of the questions. For example, we inserted the phrase "How routinely do you…" at the beginning of many questions of the Self-maintenance sub-scale, instead of using only one sentence at the beginning of subscale, as used in the original SCHFI. In addition, item 4, "Do some physical activity?" was changed to "Do you routinely do your normal life activities such shopping and cleaning?" (Riegel et al.2009; Siabani et al.2014).
In order to obtain demographic data and personal health information- as the secondary outcomes-, an investigator-constructed questionnaire has been also administered that included 13 questions about age, sex, living status (with whom they live), smoking, co-morbidities (e.g. hypertension), duration of heart failure, and the number of times a patient had been admitted to hospital due to CHF symptoms from diagnosis CHF. This information will be used to evaluate the likely association between self-care scales and personal characteristics. Data collected by three experienced trained nurses and through interviewing have been conducted at the patient’s home or hospital, according to participant preference, before intervention and two months after intervention.
Hence to have a power of 90% (σ =40, d = 22, Z α/2 = 1.96, Z β =0.1) minimum 60 participants were needed for each group.
The random number list was generated using Microsoft Excel number generator.
Allocation concealment mechanism
A registered nurse working at the medical record department at Imam Ali hospital who had collected the list of eligible subjects sent them to the study leader. The study leader provided a biostatistician, who was paid by, but not involved in the study, with the list of names and subject numbers for all 231 subjects. The biostatistician randomized the list, as described above, and then sent the list of names and subject codes with the allocated group to the study leader.
Subjects who met the selection criteria were contacted by a nurse working at the hospital and invited to participate in the study. Those who were available and agreed to participate were recruited to be interviewed. The interviews were conducted by two trained nurses. The completed questionnaires including patients’ names and numbers were sent to the study leader. The list of numbers of those completed a baseline interview were sent to the biostatistician to be randomized as described above. The allocation list provided to the study leader was then used to assign subjects to their group, 77 subjects allocated to group I (exposed to CHVs), 77 subjects to group II (formal health educators) and 77 patients to group III (control group).
Subjects were aware of where the training took place and who undertook the training and so could have been aware of the group to which they were allocated.
The first data collection occurred prior to randomization. The nurses involved in the data collection undertaken two months after the intervention were recruited to collect the data and has not have further involvement in the study. They were blinded to intervention allocation, but it is possible that the intervention allocation may have become known as a result of discussions during the data collection process.
SPSS version 21 and SAS will be used to analyse data. Using descriptive analysis for descriptive data, analytic biostatistics analysis (e.g. ANOVA, independent t-test and paired t-test) for assessing differences (between two groups, among three groups and before and after for each group) will be applied. Regression models will be used to explore associations between predicting factors (e.g. age, gender and education) and self-care scales, and also association between the effectiveness of each strategy and personal characteristics will be used. We will present frequencies and examine the expected associations between different variables to obtain answers for our research questions and hypothesis. T-tests will be used for continuous and normally distributed variables (e.g. self-care maintenance in terms of gender), chi-squared for nominal variables and other proportions (e.g. age group, sex), and multivariate generalized linear regression will be used for detecting associations between outcomes (e.g. self-care management) and explanatory variables (e.g. gender, education and disease duration). Non-parametric tests (e.g., Wilcoxon rank test and Median test) will be used when variables are found not to be normally distributed.
The characteristics of randomized control trial
Control group (Standard care)
Formal health educators
Simplified instruction for self-care provided by a GP and under supervision a cardiovascular specialist
Simplified instruction for self-care provided by a GP and under supervision of a cardiovascular specialist
Checking 25% of cases by one of investigators for intervention fidelity
An investigator attending in class without announcing
The results of this study will be reported once data analysis is completed.
This study was designed to examine the hypothesis that CHVs through a face-to-face education program offered at patients’ homes are able to train patients with CHF to care for themselves. If true, this would be a low-cost, simple and possibly more effective educational approach in order to improve self-care in patients with CHF. This strategy, especially in countries with limited resources, can minimize inequity in health services.
We would like to thank Professor. Barbara Riegel for Allowing us to translate her self-care measure and her encouraging advice in conducting the study, Dr. Farid Najafi and Dr. Masoud Mirzaei for their comments on study design, Dr. Sara Siahbani for her help in translating and validating the study instrument, Dr. Reza Khodarahmi for his official collaboration in Kermanshah University Medical Sciences (KUMS). Also, we are greatly appreciate comments from the ethics committees in KUMS and the University of Sydney.
Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences in Iran and the University of Sydney in Australia, have provided facility and financial supports for data collection and traveling fees.
- Asaei SE: Iran’s Excellent Primary Health Care System. UNICEF. 2014. Accessed 5/11/2014http://www.unicef.org/iran/media_4427.htmlGoogle Scholar
- Baker DW, Dewalt DA, Schillinger D, Hawk V, Ruo B, Bibbins-Domingo K, Weinberger M, Macabasco-O'Connell A, Grady KL, Holmes GM, Erman B, Broucksou KA, Pignone M: The effect of progressive, reinforcing telephone education and counseling versus brief educational intervention on knowledge, self-care behaviors and heart failure symptoms. J Card Fail 2011, 17(10):789-796. 10.1016/j.cardfail.2011.06.374View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Barnason S, Zimmerman L, Young L: An integrative review of interventions promoting self-care of patients with heart failure. J Clin Nurs 2012, 21(3–4):448-475. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2702.2011.03907.xView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bonow RO, Douglas LM, Douglas PZ, Peter L: Mechanisms of Cardiac Contraction and Relaxation. In Braunwald's heart disease: a textbook of cardiovascular medicine, vol 1. 9th edition. Edited by: Braunwald E. Elsevier, Indianapolis, IA, USA; 2011:459-487.Google Scholar
- Boyde M, Turner C, Thompson DR, Stewart S: Educational interventions for patients with heart failure: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. J Cardiovasc Nurs 2011, 26(4):E27-E35. 10.1097/JCN.0b013e3181ee5fb2View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Boyde M, Song S, Peters R, Turner C, Thompson DR, Stewart S: Pilot testing of a self-care education intervention for patients with heart failure. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs 2013, 12(1):39-46. doi:10.1177/1474515111430881Google Scholar
- Braunschweig F, Cowie MR, Auricchio A: What are the costs of heart failure? Europace 2011, 13(2):ii13-ii17. doi:10.1093/europace/eur081Google Scholar
- De Geest S, Steeman E, Leventhal ME, Mahrer-Imhof R, Hengartner-Kopp B, Conca A, Bernasconi AT, Petry H, Brunner-La Rocca H: Complexity in caring for an ageing heart failure population: concomitant chronic conditions and age related impairments. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs 2004, 3(4):263-270. 10.1016/j.ejcnurse.2004.08.004View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dennison CR, McEntee ML, Samuel L, Johnson BJ, Rotman S, Kielty A, Russell SD: Adequate health literacy is associated with higher heart failure knowledge and self-care confidence inhospitalized patients. J Cardiovasc Nurs 2011, 26(5):359-367. 10.1097/JCN.0b013e3181f16f88View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Giugliani C, Harzheim E, Duncan MS, Duncan BB: Effectiveness of community health workers in Brazil: a systematic review. J Ambul Care Manage 2011, 34(4):326-338. 10.1097/JAC.0b013e31822cbdfdView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Go AS, Mozaffarian D, Roger VL, Benjamin EJ, Berry JD, Borden WB, Bravata DM, Dai S, Ford ES, Fox CS, Franco S, Fullerton HJ, Gillespie C, Hailpern SM, Heit JA, Howard VJ, Huffman MD, Kissela BM, Kittner SJ, Lackland DT, Lichtman JH, Lisabeth LD, Magid D, Marcus GM, Marelli A, Matchar DB, McGuire DK, Mohler ER, Moy CS, Mussolino ME, Nichol G, Paynter NP, Schreiner PJ, Sorlie PD, Stein J, Turan TN, Virani SS, Wong ND, Woo D, Turner MB: Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2013 Update: A Report From the American Heart Association. Circulation 2013, 127(1):e6-e245. doi:10.1161/CIR.0b013e31828124ad 10.1161/CIR.0b013e31828124adView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hadi A: Management of acute respiratory infections by community health volunteers: experience of Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee (BRAC). Bull World Health Organ 2003, 81(3):183-189.Google Scholar
- Heidenreich PA, Trogdon JG, Khavjou OA, Butler J, Dracup K, Ezekowitz MD, Finkelstein EA, Hong Y, Johnston SC, Khera A, Lloyd-Jones DM, Nelson SA, Nichol G, Orenstein D, Wilson PWF, Woo YJ: Forecasting the Future of Cardiovascular Disease in the United States. Circulation 2011, 123(8):933-944. doi:10.1161/CIR.0b013e31820a55f5 10.1161/CIR.0b013e31820a55f5View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Krum H, Jelinek MV, Stewart S, Sindone A, Atherton JJ: 2011 Update to National Heart Foundation of Australia and Cardiac Society of Australia and New Zealand Guidelines for the prevention, detection and management of chronic heart failure in Australia, 2006. Med J Aust 2011, 194(8):405-409.Google Scholar
- Maes K: Examining health-care volunteerism in a food- and financially-insecure world Bull World Health Organ. 2010, 88(11):867.http://www.who.int/bulletin/volumes/88/11/09-074120/en/Google Scholar
- Malekafzali H: Volunteer women researchers are determining Iran's health and development needs. The magazine of real action and research 6. 2006. http://www.realhealthnews.net/files/RHN6%20final.pdfGoogle Scholar
- Moser DK, Dickson V, Jaarsma T, Lee C, Stromberg A, Riegel B: Role of Self-Care in the Patient with Heart Failure. Curr Cardiol Rep 2012, 14(3):265-275. doi:10.1007/s11886-012-0267-9 10.1007/s11886-012-0267-9View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Norton C, Georgiopoulou VV, Kalogeropoulos AP, Butler J: Epidemiology and Cost of Advanced Heart Failure. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 2011, 54(2):78-85.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.pcad.2011.04.002 10.1016/j.pcad.2011.04.002View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pinto E, Maso I, Pereira J, Fukuda T, Seixas J, Menezes D, Cincura C, Neville I, Jesus P, Oliveira-Filho J: Differential aspects of stroke and congestive heart failure in quality of life reduction: a case series with three comparison groups. Health Qual Life Outcomes 2011, 9(1):1-5. doi:10.1186/1477-7525-9-65 10.1186/1477-7525-9-1View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Riegel B, Lee CS, Dickson VV, Carlson B: An update on the self-care of heart failure index. J Cardiovasc Nurs 2009, 24(6):485-497. doi:10.1097/JCN.0b013e3181b4baa0 10.1097/JCN.0b013e3181b4baa0View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Siabani S, Leeder SR, Davidson PM: Barriers and facilitators to self-care in chronic heart failure: a meta-synthesis of qualitative studies. SpringerPlus 2013, 2(1):320. 10.1186/2193-1801-2-320View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Siabani S, Leeder SR, Davidson PM, Najafi F, Hamzeh B, Solimani A, Siahbani S, Driscoll T: Translation and Validation of the Self-care of Heart Failure Index Into Persian. J Cardiovasc Nurs 2014, 14: 14.Google Scholar
- Sirilak S, Okanurak K, Wattanagoon Y, Chatchaiyalerk S, Tornee S, Siri S: Community participation of cross-border migrants for primary health care in Thailand. Health Policy Plan 2013, 28(6):658-664. doi:10.1093/heapol/czs105 10.1093/heapol/czs105View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- van der Wal MHL, Jaarsma T, Moser DK, Veeger NJGM, van Gilst WH, van Veldhuisen DJ: Compliance in heart failure patients: the importance of knowledge and beliefs. Eur Heart J 2006, 27(4):434-440.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.