Skip to main content

Table 14 Comparative studies bases on values of global performance indices

From: Memetic computing through bio-inspired heuristics integration with sequential quadratic programming for nonlinear systems arising in different physical models

Methods

MFit

TMFit

GMET

GMGens

GMFEs

Values

STD

Values

STD

Values

STD

Values

STD

Values

STD

GA-1

5.59E−03

9.65E−03

7.55E−04

1.42E−03

3.18

0.20

199.86

0.34

5058.20

2380.43

GA-2

4.89E−03

6.52E−03

1.37E−03

2.29E−03

2.31

0.19

199.95

0.13

5058.28

2380.22

GA-3

8.31E−03

1.29E−02

1.85E−03

1.91E−03

2.91

0.18

200.00

0.00

5058.33

2380.09

GA-4

8.75E−03

1.39E−02

1.94E−03

2.65E−03

2.13

0.18

199.62

0.65

5054.67

2379.08

GA-5

4.38E−03

6.83E−03

6.95E−04

1.30E−03

3.16

0.17

199.82

0.44

5058.16

2380.52

GA-6

4.38E−03

5.55E−03

1.41E−03

2.34E−03

2.37

0.18

199.97

0.08

5058.30

2380.17

GA-7

8.18E−03

1.33E−02

1.53E−03

1.97E−03

2.98

0.17

199.98

0.04

5058.32

2380.13

GA-8

8.81E−03

1.36E−02

2.31E−03

3.21E−03

2.19

0.18

199.51

1.19

5057.85

2381.28

GA-9

6.36E−03

1.11E−02

7.73E−04

1.39E−03

3.11

0.18

200.00

0.00

5058.33

2380.09

GA-10

7.99E−03

1.30E−02

1.54E−03

2.37E−03

2.32

0.18

200.00

0.00

5058.33

2380.09

GA-11

1.36E−02

2.44E−02

2.68E−03

2.46E−03

2.93

0.19

200.00

0.00

5058.33

2380.09

GA-12

1.23E−02

2.13E−02

2.62E−03

3.16E−03

2.14

0.19

199.38

0.84

5045.19

2374.33

GA-SQP-1

3.08E−03

6.02E−03

5.11E−09

1.25E−08

18.12

11.06

465.80

69.13

15,143.54

11,238.70

GA-SQP-2

2.04E−03

3.48E−03

6.92E−09

1.69E−08

17.77

10.38

465.14

59.07

14,933.64

10,933.65

GA-SQP-3

1.15E−03

2.54E−03

1.04E−09

2.54E−09

18.65

10.68

474.61

51.65

15,249.61

11,335.91

GA-SQP-4

2.20E−03

5.11E−03

1.40E−09

3.44E−09

18.65

10.03

476.99

37.35

14,872.66

10,776.58

GA-SQP-5

2.01E−03

3.46E−03

6.83E−09

1.67E−08

18.14

10.82

467.63

66.56

15,082.10

11,289.61

GA-SQP-6

1.78E−03

2.83E−03

7.01E−09

1.72E−08

17.80

11.24

465.34

71.46

15,235.05

11,342.57

GA-SQP-7

1.72E−03

3.37E−03

1.96E−09

4.79E−09

18.21

10.41

469.76

49.04

14,831.32

10,948.08

GA-SQP-8

2.20E−03

4.21E−03

5.82E−09

1.42E−08

18.76

10.55

476.41

37.61

15,061.59

11,228.61

GA-SQP-9

3.86E−03

7.58E−03

5.66E−09

1.39E−08

18.08

10.52

471.06

49.41

15,023.15

11,113.62

GA-SQP-10

3.24E−03

6.05E−03

8.23E−09

2.02E−08

17.53

10.32

470.43

53.49

14,770.72

10,847.38

GA-SQP-11

2.29E−03

5.08E−03

1.46E−09

3.59E−09

18.48

10.82

471.66

45.47

15,077.75

11,445.12

GA-SQP-12

2.53E−03

4.86E−03

7.25E−09

1.78E−08

18.33

10.23

477.27

31.12

14,698.36

10,850.71