Table 12 Wilcoxon’s rank sum test results (generations = 5000 and dimensions = 50)
From: Particle swarm optimization using multi-information characteristics of all personal-best information
Name | Â | PSO-API and PSO | LPSO-API and LPSO |
|---|---|---|---|
f 1(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.786e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 2(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 3(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 4(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 5(x) | p/h/z | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 | 2.457e−005/1/−4.218e+000 |
f 6(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 7(x) | p/h/z | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 |
f 8(x) | p/h/z | 3.046e−008/1/−5.538e+000 | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 |
f 9(x) | p/h/z | 3.959e−008/1/−5.492e+000 | 3.290e−008/1/−5.525e+000 |
f 10(x) | p/h/z | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 |
f 11(x) | p/h/z | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 |
f 12(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 4.600e−004/−1/3.502e+000 |
f 13(x) | p/h/z | 8.006e−009/1/−5.768e+000 | 7.991e−009/1/−5.768e+000 |
f 14(x) | p/h/z | 5.726e−008/1/−5.427e+000 | 4.505e−007/1/−5.046e+000 |
f 15(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.786e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 16(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 17(x) | p/h/z | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 | 6.795e−008/1/−5.396e+000 |
f 18(x) | p/h/z | 1.055e−002/−1/2.557e+000 | 1.194e−006/1/−4.856e+000 |
f 19(x) | p/h/z | 4.165e−005/−1/4.098e+000 | 4.600e−004/−1/3.502e+000 |
f 20(x) | p/h/z | 3.938e−007/−1/5.071e+000 | 6.795e−008/−1/5.396e+000 |
| Â | 1 | 17 | 17 |
| Â | 0 | 0 | 0 |
|  | −1 | 3 | 3 |