Skip to main content

Table 2 Ordering of the alternatives for different \(\gamma\)

From: Some series of intuitionistic fuzzy interactive averaging aggregation operators

\(\gamma\)

Approach

Score function by IFHIWA

Score function by IFHIOWA

Score function by IFHIHWA

\(S(x_1)\)

\(S(x_2)\)

\(S(x_3)\)

Ranking

\(S(x_1)\)

\(S(x_2)\)

\(S(x_3)\)

Ranking

\(S(x_1)\)

\(S(x_2)\)

\(S(x_3)\)

Ranking

0.1

Proposed

0.1386

0.1298

0.0060

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

0.1386

0.1298

0.0060

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

0.1790

0.1260

0.0294

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1984

0.1878

0.0464

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1984

0.1878

0.0464

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.2280

0.2227

0.0811

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.5

Proposed

0.1214

0.1183

−0.0039

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

0.1214

0.1183

−0.0039

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

0.1625

0.1107

0.0211

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1722

0.1627

0.0288

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1722

0.1627

0.0288

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.2105

0.2072

0.0746

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

1.0

Proposed

0.1099

0.1099

−0.0114

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1099

0.1099

−0.0114

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1530

0.0996

0.0157

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1588

0.1498

0.0178

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1588

0.1498

0.0178

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.2023

0.2007

0.0721

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

1.5

Proposed

0.1029

0.1045

−0.0163

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1029

0.1045

−0.0163

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1479

0.0925

0.0127

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1514

0.1425

0.0112

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1514

0.1425

0.0112

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1982

0.1978

0.0715

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

2.0

Proposed

0.0981

0.1007

−0.0199

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0981

0.1007

−0.0199

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1443

0.0876

0.0108

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1467

0.1377

0.0068

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1467

0.1377

0.0068

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1960

0.1964

0.0716

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

3.0

Proposed

0.0918

0.0957

−0.0247

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0918

0.0957

−0.0247

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1400

0.0810

0.0087

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1408

0.1316

0.0011

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1408

0.1316

0.0011

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1937

0.1941

0.0725

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

5.0

Proposed

0.0851

0.0902

−0.0300

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0851

0.0902

−0.0300

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1362

0.0738

0.0073

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1349

0.1253

−0.0049

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1349

0.1253

−0.0049

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1926

0.1923

0.0753

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

10

Proposed

0.0785

0.0847

−0.0354

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0785

0.0847

−0.0354

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1337

0.0663

0.0074

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1293

0.1192

−0.0107

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1293

0.1192

−0.0107

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1941

0.1925

0.0783

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

25

Proposed

0.0736

0.0804

−0.0396

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0736

0.0804

−0.0396

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1340

0.0596

0.0105

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1252

0.1147

−0.0151

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1252

0.1147

−0.0151

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.2006

0.1962

0.0803

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

50

Proposed

0.0717

0.0788

−0.0412

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0717

0.0788

−0.0412

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1355

0.0563

0.0108

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1237

0.1130

−0.0167

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1237

0.1130

−0.0167

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.2074

0.1918

0.0761

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

100

Proposed

0.0707

0.0779

−0.0421

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.0707

0.0779

−0.0421

\(x_2 \succ x_1 \succ x_3\)

0.1369

0.0535

0.0112

\(x_1 \succ x_2 \succ x_3\)

Liu (2014)

0.1229

0.1122

−0.0175

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.1229

0.1122

−0.0175

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)

0.2052

0.1888

0.0731

\(x_1\succ x_2\succ x_3\)