A
|
Numerical frequency \(\omega_{e}\)
|
Hamdan and Dado (1997) (error%)
|
Wu et al. (2003) (error%)
|
Present method (error%) \(\omega_{0}\)
|
---|
\(\omega_{0}\)
|
\(\omega_{1}\)
|
\(\omega_{0}\)
|
\(\omega_{1}\)
|
---|
5
|
1.34288
|
1.20953
|
1.24841
|
1.20953
|
1.32217
|
1.37581
|
9.93
|
7.04
|
9.93
|
1.54
|
2.45
|
10
|
1.38928
|
1.22074
|
1.26285
|
1.22074
|
1.35084
|
1.40388
|
12.13
|
9.10
|
12.13
|
2.77
|
1.05
|
15
|
1.40138
|
1.22295
|
1.26570
|
1.22295
|
1.35672
|
1.40955
|
12.73
|
9.68
|
12.73
|
3.19
|
0.58
|
20
|
1.40632
|
1.22373
|
1.26671
|
1.22373
|
1.35883
|
1.41158
|
12.98
|
9.92
|
12.98
|
3.38
|
0.38
|
25
|
1.40883
|
1.22409
|
1.26718
|
1.22409
|
1.35981
|
1.41252
|
13.11
|
10.05
|
13.11
|
3.48
|
0.26
|
30
|
1.41029
|
1.22429
|
1.26743
|
1.22429
|
1.36035
|
1.41304
|
13.19
|
10.13
|
13.19
|
3.54
|
0.20
|
50
|
1.41261
|
1.22458
|
1.26781
|
1.22458
|
1.36113
|
1.41379
|
13.31
|
10.25
|
13.31
|
3.65
|
0.08
|
100
|
1.41375
|
1.22470
|
1.26797
|
1.22470
|
1.36147
|
1.41411
|
13.37
|
10.31
|
13.37
|
3.70
|
0.03
|
200
|
1.41408
|
1.22473
|
1.26801
|
1.22473
|
1.36155
|
1.41419
|
13.39
|
10.33
|
13.39
|
3.72
|
0.00
|
500
|
1.41419
|
1.22474
|
1.26802
|
1.22474
|
1.36157
|
1.41421
|
13.40
|
10.33
|
13.40
|
3.72
|
0.00
|
1000
|
1.41421
|
1.22474
|
1.26802
|
1.22474
|
1.36157
|
1.41421
|
13.40
|
10.33
|
13.40
|
3.72
|
0.00
|
- The absolute relative error has been also computed