Skip to main content

Table 1 GBL fit for first digit of powerful integer powers: MAD vs. WLS criterion

From: A first digit theorem for powerful integer powers

s = 1

Parameters

Δ to LL estimate

MAD GoF measures

WLS GoF measures

m =

WLS

MAD

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

8

0.50630179

0.50602471

1.819

1.947

282.9

135.2

134.6

90.14

28.44

28.75

9

0.50398677

0.50439385

2.298

1.890

168.3

90.24

86.04

66.89

21.19

22.62

10

0.50258542

0.50277813

2.755

2.340

92.13

45.33

45.02

42.88

12.36

13.05

11

0.50170493

0.50180536

3.116

2.650

44.37

17.57

16.34

22.63

4.505

4.911

12

0.50116789

0.50121344

2.932

2.477

19.77

8.163

7.927

8.998

1.546

1.726

13

0.50080206

0.50083278

2.077

1.415

6.993

4.335

4.077

2.519

0.784

0.960

14

0.50054625

0.50054722

0.289

0.244

1.821

1.802

1.794

0.345

0.330

0.330

15

0.50037082

0.50036094

3.110

2.122

2.042

1.252

1.200

1.154

0.315

0.400

s = 2

Parameters

Δ to LL estimate

MAD GoF measures

WLS GoF measures

m =

WLS

MAD

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

8

0.25428436

0.25324296

0.383

0.867

238.4

218.8

193.9

163.9

157.8

167.6

9

0.25428436

0.25267279

1.142

0.469

76.66

122.8

59.30

28.98

66.02

28.52

10

0.25166049

0.25155591

0.585

0.811

26.64

19.31

18.58

7.514

4.409

4.870

11

0.25096820

0.25089373

1.021

1.366

22.15

15.50

13.56

10.95

6.568

7.071

12

0.25062939

0.25059921

1.012

1.314

11.19

8.423

7.972

6.168

4.169

4.347

13

0.25042363

0.25041307

0.552

0.779

3.923

3.055

2.805

1.563

1.287

1.334

14

0.25028419

0.25028723

0.369

0.510

1.533

1.302

1.238

0.540

0.482

0.491

15

0.25018970

0.25019163

1.984

2.177

1.344

0.640

0.624

1.027

0.258

0.266

s = 3

Parameters

Δ to LL estimate

MAD GoF measures

WLS GoF measures

m =

WLS

MAD

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

8

0.16900766

0.16723059

0.495

1.319

274.3

257.7

248.0

575.4

553.1

615.3

9

0.16801302

0.16762481

0.748

1.137

116.4

89.18

81.67

142.8

119.1

125.5

10

0.16769485

0.16753300

0.560

0.909

60.96

58.26

57.25

124.0

117.8

120.2

11

0.16729754

0.16730322

0.748

0.722

18.31

13.37

13.25

24.45

19.34

19.35

12

0.16710133

0.16708812

0.524

0.656

7.100

5.652

5.371

6.058

4.895

4.969

13

0.16695408

0.16695069

0.260

0.333

3.798

3.374

3.255

3.664

3.530

3.541

14

0.16685701

0.16685618

0.287

0.249

2.484

2.358

2.338

3.931

3.856

3.857

15

0.16679314

0.16679442

1.323

1.452

1.321

0.972

0.952

2.021

1.279

1.286

s = 4

Parameters

Δ to LL estimate

MAD GoF measures

WLS GoF measures

m =

WLS

MAD

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

8

0.12774699

0.12760514

0.089

0.023

336.0

339.0

334.9

1704

1702

1703

9

0.12682400

0.12682674

0.253

0.256

108.7

100.3

100.2

495.4

489.5

489.6

10

0.12592594

0.12589200

0.086

0.160

38.75

37.58

36.59

149.2

148.9

149.1

11

0.12543815

0.12539409

0.724

0.928

21.98

16.83

15.38

52.95

42.62

43.45

12

0.12530767

0.12526505

0.576

1.002

7.884

6.275

5.841

18.01

14.97

16.63

13

0.12521961

0.12520948

0.108

0.326

4.885

4.688

4.291

20.84

20.79

20.99

14

0.12514734

0.12514391

0.428

0.269

1.315

1.279

1.181

4.693

4.331

4.381

15

0.12509739

0.12509771

1.246

1.278

0.940

0.587

0.579

3.039

1.619

1.620

s = 5

Parameters

Δ to LL estimate

MAD GoF measures

WLS GoF measures

m =

WLS

MAD

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

LL

WLS

MAD

8

0.10483305

0.10494392

1.295

1.346

551.6

498.4

496.2

8531

7818

7819

9

0.10110871

0.10166842

0.148

0.412

182.7

185.4

175.0

2055

2051

2113

10

0.10041545

0.10050001

0.770

0.588

39.74

30.51

28.02

211.5

157.1

160.2

11

0.10035943

0.10038750

0.538

0.407

21.67

19.45

18.85

124.1

111.8

112.5

12

0.10021129

0.10018888

0.809

1.033

10.05

8.099

7.558

60.76

47.82

48.81

13

0.10015612

0.10013482

0.508

0.967

5.373

4.752

4.238

35.74

33.38

35.31

14

0.10011058

0.10010322

0.004

0.337

1.790

1.792

1.653

9.827

9.827

10.32

15

0.10007403

0.10007147

0.609

0.353

0.794

0.713

0.655

4.477

3.745

3.874