Skip to main content

Table 4 Search themes case studies

From: The controversy of sports technology: a systematic review

Sport

Sport technology

Reference

Aeromodelling

Whether such technology is a competitive sport

Norris (2011)

Amateur boxing

Increase in head injuries caused by boxers feeling they have an increased invulnerability

Dyer et al. (2010)

America’s Cup yachting

Hull design

Nafziger (2004)

American football

The replacement of leather headgear by plastic helmets

Miah (2005); Gelberg (1995)

Athletics with a disability (100–400 m running)

Oscar Pistorius prosthetic legs

Baker (2015); Wolbring and Tynedal (2013); Marcellini et al. (2012); Wolbring (2012); Burkett et al. (2011); Scholz et al. (2011); Dyer et al. (2011); Howe (2011); van Hilvoorde and Landeweerd (2008); Dyer et al. (2010); Burkett (2010); Murray (2010); Jones and Wilson (2009); Moses (2009); Lea (2009); Weyand et al. (2009); Zettler (2009); Grabowski et al. (2009); Swartz and Watermeyer (2008); Mokha and Conrey (2007); Hutzler (2008); Edwards (2008); Wolbring (2008)

Athletics with a disability (Long Jump)

Markus Rehm prosthetic leg

Baker (2015)

Cricket

Line call technology

Collins and Evans (2011); Collins (2010); Collins and Evans (2008); Singh (2012)

Cycling

Obree ‘tuck position’ (reskilling based technology)

Trabal (2008)

Cycling

Use of the rear gear derailleur in the Tour de France

Trabal (2008)

Cycling

Obree ‘tuck’ or ‘superman position’ (reskilling based technology)

Miah (2006); Trabal (2008)

Distance running

Chip timing

Sailors (2009)

Fishing

Introduction of the spinning reel

Miah (2006); Hummel and Foster (1986)

Football

Use of goal-line technology/refereeing

Svantesson (2014); Singh (2012); Nlandu (2012); Collins (2010)

Golf

Casey Martin’s use of a golf cart

Baker (2015); Burkett et al. (2011); Dyer et al. (2010); Hutzler (2008); Charlish and Riley (2008); Francis (2005)

Golf

‘U’ grooves in golf club heads

Carr (2008); Miah (2006); Gardner (1989)

Golf

Croquet style putter

Carr (2008)

Golf

‘Polara’ golf ball

Dyer et al. (2011)

Golf

Introduction of rubber cored golf ball

Vamplew (2007)

Golf

Golf ball and arguments between two governing bodies over use of steel shafts in the 1950’s

Vamplew (2007)

Ice hockey

Argued mandatory use of goalie face masks

Bachynski (2012)

Ice skating

Use of ‘Klapskates’

van Hilvoorde et al. (2007)

Marathon running

Use of wheelchairs at Boston Marathon in 1975

Hutzler (2008)

Pole vault

Use of glass fibre for pole

Dyer et al. (2010); VerSteeg (2005)

Pole vault

Digging of hole to plant pole into.

VerSteeg (2005)

Rowing

Movable handles (roller skiff)

Trabal (2008)

Swimming

Full body swimsuits being hydrodynamically superior

Foster et al. (2012); Stefani (2012); Craik (2011); Partridge (2011); James (2010); Burkett (2010); Zettler (2009); Lea (2009); Mountjoy et al. (2009); Magdalinski (2000)

Tennis

Use of ‘Hawk-eye’ line judge technology

Collins and Evans (2008, 2011); Collins (2010)

Tennis

‘Spaghetti strung’ rackets

Dyer et al. (2011); Dyer et al. (2010); Sheridan (2006); Savulescu (2006)

Tennis

Ball size and material composition

Sheridan (2006); Miah (2000)

Various

Use of hypoxic chambers

James (2010); Loland and Caplan (2008); Spriggs (2005); Miah (2006); Miah (2005)

Wrestling

Use of video-taped evidence

Nafziger (2004)