Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparative analysis of preference rankings of individual traits of female animals used as selection criteria across the three West African cities of Kano (Nigeria), Bobo Dioulasso (Burkina Faso) and Sikasso (Mali)

From: Production objectives and breeding practices of urban goat and sheep keepers in West Africa: regional analysis and implications for the development of supportive breeding programs

Traits

Sheep

Goats

Mean ranka (Rank)

Mean ranka (Rank)

Kano (n = 100)

Bobo Dioulasso (n = 102)

Sikasso (n = 99)

Kano (n = 100)

Bobo Dioulasso (n = 99)

Sikasso (n = 107)

Good body conformation

4.51aA

(3)

7.52Bfad

(8)

8.02Baf

(7)

2.85aA

(2)

7.40Bad

(8)

8.04Ca

(6)

Good apparent health status

3.23bA

(1)

3.44Ab

(1)

2.25Ab

(1)

2.76aA

(1)

3.30Ab

(1)

2.36Ab

(2)

Big body size

4.40Aa

(2)

4.56Ac

(2)

3.05Bbc

(3)

7.42bgA

(8)

5.56Bc

(5)

6.47Ac

(5)

Breed

6.06Ac

(6)

4.63Bc

(3)

8.96Cdi

(10)

6.75bcgA

(7)

5.50Bc

(4)

8.50Ad

(9)

Coat colour

8.74Ad

(11)

7.09Bd

(6)

2.92Cc

(2)

8.78dA

(11)

7.16Ba

(6)

5.57Ce

(4)

Big udder size

7.88Ae

(8)

8.28Be

(12)

4.41Ce

(4)

8.96dA

(12)

8.24Ae

(11)

3.48Bf

(3)

Rapid growth

4.82Aa

(4)

8.17Baef

(11)

7.46Cf

(6)

6.44ceA

(5)

8.30Be

(12)

8.17Ca

(8)

Young age

7.60Ae

(7)

7.71Afg

(9)

5.97Bg

(5)

5.86efA

(4)

7.67Bda

(9)

8.05Ba

(7)

Resistance to disease

7.95Ae

(9)

5.67Bh

(4)

8.20Aah

(8)

6.57bcA

(6)

4.98Bc

(3)

1.88Cg

(1)

Easy feeding

5.77Ac

(5)

5.69Ah

(5)

8.64Bdh

(9)

5.36fA

(3)

4.84Ac

(2)

8.50Bd

(10)

Docility/temperament

8.33Ad

(10)

7.16Bd

(7)

9.06 Ci

(11)

8.65dA

(10)

7.20Bfa

(7)

8.50Cd

(11)

Tolerance to drought

8.74Ad

(12)

8.08Aeg

(10)

9.09Bi

(12)

7.63gA

(9)

7.87Bed

(10)

8.50Cd

(12)

  1. aMeans in columns followed by different lowercase letters are different at the Bonferroni-adjusted significance level p ≤ 0.002 (Friedman test followed by Wilcoxon signed-rank post hoc tests with Bonferroni’s correction for multiple comparisons); Means of the same species (sheep or goat) followed by different uppercase letters in rows are different at p ≤ 0.05 (Kruskall Wallis test followed by Mann–Whitney U tests).