From: Measuring competence in central venous catheterization: a systematic-review
Study | Observers | Learner population | No. of learners observed | No. of procedures observed | Live vs video | Sites tested | Ultrasound used | Evaluations on patients (clinical) vs simulators | Checklist used (y/n); no of items | Global rating scale used (y/n); no. of items | Additional items assessed (y/n); no. of items |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Barsuk et al. (2009c) | Faculty | MICU residents | 28 | N/A | Live and video | IJ, SC | Y | Simulators | Y; 27 | N | N |
Barsuk et al. (2009a) | Faculty | Nephrology fellows | 18 | N/A | Live and video | IJ | Y | Simulators | Y; 27 | N | N |
Berenholtz et al. (2004) | Nurses | ICU residents | N/A | 64 | Live | N/A | N/A | Clinical | Y; 8 | N | N |
Blaivas and Adhikari (2009) | Faculty | Emergency medicine residents | 25 | 25 | Live | IJ | Y | Simulators | Y; 2 | N | Y; 1 |
Britt et al. (2009) | Trauma fellow or critical care surgeon | Junior surgery residents | 34 | 73 | Live | N/A | N/A | Clinical | Y; 14 | Y; 2 | Y; 1 |
Carvalho (2007) | Medical students | Medical students | 9 | N/A | Live | IJ, SC | Y | Simulators | Y; 1 | N | Y; 2 |
Coopersmith et al. (2002) | Nurses | Residents in surgery, anesthesiology, emergency medicine, nurse practioner | N/A | 16 | Live | IJ, SC, Fem | N/A | Clinical | Y; 9 | N | N |
Costello et al. (2008) | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | Live | IJ, SC, Fem | N/A | Clinical | Y; 18 | N | N |
Dong et al. (2010) | Faculty and Fellow | Residents in anesthesiology, internal medicine, emergency medicine, general surgery, attending faculty | 105 | N/A | Video | IJ, SC | Y | Simulators | Y; 15 | N | Y; 3 |
Evans et al. (2009) | Hired independent raters | PGY-1 and PGY-2 residents | N/A | N/A | Live and video | IJ, SC, Fem | Y | Simulators | Y; 63 | N | Y; 2 |
Huang et al. (2009) | Faculty | Internal Medicine residents | 42 | 94 | Video | SC | N | Simulators | Y; 22 | Y; 1 | Y; 1 |
Kilbourne et al. (2009) | Study authors | Surgical or emergency medicine residents | N/A | 86 | Video | SC | N | Clinical | Y;6 | N | Y; 2 |
Lee et al. (2009) | Expert reviewers | Emergency medicine residents | 16 | N/A | Video | IJ | Y | Simulators | Y; 19 | Y;1 | Y;2 |
Lobo et al. (2005) | Infection control staff | Medical residents | N/A | 44 | Live | IJ, SC, Fem | N/A | Clinical | Y;9 | N | N |
McKee et al. (2008) | Nurses | Pediatric anesthesiologists, surgeons, pediatric surgical staff, critical care medical staff | N/A | 43 | Live | N/A | N/A | Clinical | Y; 5 | N | N |
Millington et al. (2009) | Faculty | Medical residents | 30 | N/A | Video | IJ | N | Simulators | Y; 10 | Y;5 | Y;3 |
Murphy et al. (2008) | “Assessors” | Medical students | 30 | N/A | Video | IJ | N | Simulator | Y;20 | Y;7 | Y;1 |
Papadimos et al. (2008) | Independent observers | Residents in anesthesiology and surgery | N/A | 85 | Live | N/A | Available | Clinical | Y; 7 | N | N |
Ramakrishna et al. (2005) | Cardiologists | PGY2 medical residents | 20 | N/A | Live | IJ | Available | Clinical | Y;7 | Y;1 | N |
Rosen et al. (2009) | Senior medical residents | Incoming medical residents | 20 | 60 | Live | IJ | Y | Chickens | Y; 22 | N | N |
Stone et al. (2010) | Faculty | Senior medical students and PGY-1 emergency medicine residents | 39 | N/A | Live | N/A | Y | Simulators | Y; 1 | N | Y; 1 |
Velmahos et al. (2004) | Faculty | Surgical interns | 26 | N/A | Live | N | N | Clinical | Y;15 | N | Y;3 |
Wall et al. (2005) | Nurses | “Trainees” in MICU | N/A | ≥5 | Live | IJ, SC, Fem | N/A | Clinical | Y;22 | N | Y; 2 |
Xiao et al. (2007) | Faculty | Trauma residents | 50 | 73 | Video | IJ, SC, Fem | N/A | Clinical | Y;13 | N | N |
Yilmaz et al. (2007) | N/A | N/A | N/A | 356 | Live | N/A | N/A | Clinical | Y; 2 | N | N |