Skip to main content

Table 3 The performance result on la01 to la40

From: A synergetic combination of small and large neighborhood schemes in developing an effective procedure for solving the job shop scheduling problem

   

SLENP

Instance

Size

BKS

Best

%DEV best

Tbest(s)

Avg

Tavg(s)

la01

10 × 5

666

666

0.000

0.00

666

0.00

la02

10 × 5

655

655

0.000

0.06

655

0.07

la03

10 × 5

597

597

0.000

0.06

597

0.09

la04

10 × 5

590

590

0.000

0.05

590

0.06

la05

10 × 5

593

593

0.000

0.00

593

0.00

la06

15 × 5

926

926

0.000

0.00

926

0.00

la07

15 × 5

890

890

0.000

0.00

890

0.01

la08

15 × 5

863

863

0.000

0.00

863

0.00

la09

15 × 5

951

951

0.000

0.00

951

0.00

la10

15 × 5

958

958

0.000

0.00

958

0.00

la11

20 × 5

1222

1222

0.000

0.00

1222

0.00

la12

20 × 5

1039

1039

0.000

0.00

1039

0.00

la13

20 × 5

1150

1150

0.000

0.00

1150

0.00

la14

20 × 5

1292

1292

0.000

0.00

1292

0.00

la15

20 × 5

1207

1207

0.000

0.02

1207

0.15

la16

10 × 10

945

945

0.000

0.13

945

0.69

la17

10 × 10

784

784

0.000

0.11

784

0.13

la18

10 × 10

848

848

0.000

0.12

848

0.16

la19

10 × 10

842

842

0.000

0.16

842

0.51

la20

10 × 10

902

902

0.000

0.14

902

0.20

la21

15 × 10

1046

1046

0.000

2.68

1046.8

14.58

la22

15 × 10

927

927

0.000

0.72

927

5.50

la23

15 × 10

1032

1032

0.000

0.23

1032

0.24

la24

15 × 10

935

935

0.000

4.04

935.2

22.75

la25

15 × 10

977

977

0.000

1.51

977.2

10.97

la26

20 × 10

1218

1218

0.000

0.41

1218

0.44

la27

20 × 10

1235

1235

0.000

2.06

1235

27.79

la28

20 × 10

1211

1216

0.413

0.45

1216

0.79

la29

20 × 10

1152

1163

0.955

25.80

1164.3

32.50

la30

20 × 10

1355

1355

0.000

0.38

1355

0.40

la31

30 × 10

1784

1784

0.000

0.68

1784

0.70

la32

30 × 10

1850

1850

0.000

0.02

1850

0.04

la33

30 × 10

1719

1719

0.000

0.23

1719

0.70

la34

30 × 10

1721

1721

0.000

0.66

1721

0.67

la35

30 × 10

1888

1888

0.000

0.74

1888

0.77

la36

15 × 15

1268

1268

0.000

5.28

1268.4

16.01

la37

15 × 15

1397

1397

0.000

1.12

1397

3.89

la38

15 × 15

1196

1196

0.000

1.75

1199.2

14.18

la39

15 × 15

1233

1233

0.000

6.54

1235.4

21.19

la40

15 × 15

1222

1225

0.245

25.12

1227.1

17.95