Skip to main content

Table 8 Performance comparisons OTLBO, JADE, jDE ,SaDE,CoDE, EPSDE

From: A teaching learning based optimization based on orthogonal design for solving global optimization problems

Function FEs   SaDE jDE JADE CoDE EPSDE OTLBO Significant
Sphere 1.5× 105 Mean 4.5e-20 2.5e-28 1.8e-60 1.12e-31 1.53e-85 0 +
   Std 1.9e-14 3.5e-28 8.4e-60 3.45-31 9.01e-86 0  
Schwefel 2.22 2.0× 105 Mean 1.9e-14 1.5e-23 1.8e-25 1.22e-23 3.18e-54 0 +
   Std 1.1e-14 1.0e-23 8.8e-25 3.90e-23 3.11e-54 0  
Schwefel 1.2 5.0× 105 Mean 9.0e-37 5.2e-14 5.7e-61 7.86e-31 4.81e-76 0 +
   Std 5.4e-36 1.1e-13 2.7e-60 1.86e-32 1.90e-76 0  
Step 1.0× 104 Mean 9.3e+02 1.0e+03 2.9e+0 3.00e+00 0 0 NA
   Std 1.8e+02 2.2e+02 1.2e+0 1.90E+00 0 0  
Rastrigin 1.0× 105 Mean 1.2e-03 1.5e-04 1.0e-04 1.21e-01 0 0 NA
   Std 6.5e-04 2.0e-04 6.0e-05 3.89e-02 0 0  
Schwefel 2.21 5.0× 105. Mean 7.4e-11 1.4e-15 8.2e-24 2.44e-27 1.94e-2 0 +
   Std 1.82e-10 1.0e-15 4.0e-23 1.89e-27 8.90e-4 0  
kley 5.0× 104 Mean 2.7e-03 3.5e-04 8.2e-10 1.18e-04 5.36e-13 2.78e-15 +
   Std 5.1e-04 1.0e-04 6.9e-10 4.90e-04 4.77e-14 1.56e-15  
Griewank 5.0× 104 Mean 7.8e-04 1.9e-05 9.9e-08 1.74e-07 0 0 NA
   Std 1.2e-03 5.8e-05 6.0e-07 2.33e-07 0 0