A secularly varying hemispheric climate-signal propagation previously detected in instrumental and proxy data not detected in CMIP3 data base

Wyatt, Marcia Glaze; Peters, John M

doi:10.1186/2193-1801-1-68

SpringerPlus

Table 4 Summary of all analyses whose results included at least one statistically significant mode (p < 5%)

From: A secularly varying hemispheric climate-signal propagation previously detected in instrumental and proxy data not detected in CMIP3 data base

RC #	Group	Period	Model	Experiment	Run	Significant w/ annual sampling	Significant w/ 5y rm sampling	Comments
1	single	~70y	CCMA_cgcm3	20c	1	yes	no	no propagation
1,2	pair	bi-annual	CNRM_cm3	20c	1	yes	no	high-frequency
1,2	pair	bi-annual	CNRM_cm3	20c	1	yes	no	no propagation
3	single	~25y	CNRM_cm3	20c	1	yes	no	no propagation
3	single	~25y	CNRM_cm3	20c	1	yes	no	non-stationary
3	single	sub-decadal	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	yes	no	no propagation
3	single	sub-decadal	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	yes	no	non-stationary
5	single	sub-decadal	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	yes	no	no propagation
5	single	sub-decadal	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	yes	no	non-stationary
6,7	pair	bi-annual	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	yes	no	no propagation
6,7	pair	bi-annual	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	yes	no	non-stationary
1	single	~70y	CSIRO_mk3	20c	1	no	yes	no propagation
1,2	pair	~35y	GFDL_2_0	20c	1	marginal	yes	no propagation
1,2	pair	~35y	GFDL_2_1	20c	3	no	marginal	no propagation
1	single	~100y	IAP_fgoals_1_0	20c	1	yes	yes	no propagation
2,3	pair	bi-annual	IAP_fgoals_1_0	20c	1	yes	no	non-stationary
1	single	inter-annual	MIUB_echo_0	20c	2	yes		high-frequency
								non-stationary
								no propagation
1	single	~60y	MIUB_echo_0	20c	2		yes	no propagation
2	single	~60y	MIUB_echo_0	20c	2	yes	no	no propagation
3	single	~25y	MIUB_echo_0	20c	2	yes	no	no propagation
3	single	~55y	UKMO_hadcm	20c	1	marginal	no	no propagation
1	single	~50y	CNRM_cm3	control	1	n/a	marginal	no propagation
2	single	~25y	CSIRO_mk3	control	1	n/a	yes	no propagation
1	single	~55-75y	GFDL_2_0	control	1	n/a	yes	no propagation
2	single	~25y	GFDL_2_0	control	1	n/a	yes	no propagation

Of all analyses with statistically significant modes identified, none capture a propagating signal.

Back to article page