From: Software project management tools in global software development: a systematic mapping study
Article | Type | Approach | Quality assessment | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
QA1 | QA2 | QA3 | QA4 | Score | |||
Sinha et al. (2006) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | Q1 | 5.0 |
Ramasubbu and Balan (2012) | Solution proposal | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE A* | 5.0 |
Treude and Storey (2012) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | Q1 | 5.0 |
Niinimaki et al. (2010) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | Q2 | 4.5 |
Gorton et al. (1997b) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE A | 4.5 |
Palacio et al. (2011) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | Q3 | 4.0 |
Lanubile et al. (2010) | Review | Other | Yes | Yes | No | Q1 | 4.0 |
Portillo-RodrÃguez et al. (2012) | Review | Other | Yes | Yes | No | Q1 | 4.0 |
Persson et al. (2009) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | Q3 | 4.0 |
Bowen and Maurer (2002) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE A* | 4.0 |
Al-Ani et al. (2014) | Evaluation research | Survey | Yes | No | Yes | Q1 | 4.0 |
Samoilenko and Nahar (2012a) | Evaluation research | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE A | 3.5 |
Samoilenko and Nahar (2012b) | Evaluation research | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE A | 3.5 |
Scharff et al. (2010) | Evaluation research | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Costa et al. (2010) | Review | Other | Yes | Yes | No | CORE A | 3.5 |
Spanjers et al. (2006) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Goedicke et al. (2000) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE A | 3.5 |
Herring and Rees (2001) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Sakthivel (2005) | Other | Other | Yes | Yes | No | Q2 | 3.5 |
Dullemond and van Gameren (2012) | Solution proposal | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Prause et al. (2010) | Evaluation research | Survey | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Dullemond et al. (2010) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Mullick et al. (2006) | Evaluation research | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Niinimaki and Lassenius (2008) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Tell and Ali Babar (2011a) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE A | 3.5 |
Liukkunen et al. (2010) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Jaanu et al. (2012) | Evaluation research | Survey | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Gupta and Fernandez (2011) | Solution proposal | Survey | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Geisser et al. (2007) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Winkler et al. (2010) | Evaluation research | Experiment | Yes | No | Yes | CORE A | 3.5 |
Dullemond and van Gameren (2013) | Solution proposal | Survey | Yes | Yes | Yes | CORE C | 3.5 |
Miyamoto et al. (2012) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 3.0 |
Thissen et al. (2007) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | No | Yes | CORE B | 3.0 |
Gorton et al. (1997a) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 3.0 |
Lam and Maheshwari (2001) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE B | 3.0 |
Surjaputra and Maheshwari (1999) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE B | 3.0 |
Simmons and Ma (2006) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE B | 3.0 |
Prikladnicki et al. (2012) | Review | Other | Yes | No | No | Q1 | 3.0 |
Giuffrida and Dittrich (2011) | Evaluation research | Case study | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 3.0 |
Beecham et al. (2012) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 3.0 |
Lanubile et al. (2013) | Evaluation research | Theory | Yes | No | No | Q1 | 3.0 |
Portillo-RodrÃguez et al. (2014) | Review | Other | Partially | Yes | No | Q1 | 3.0 |
Eskeli et al. (2011) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Wesslin et al. (2011) | Other | Other | Partially | Yes | No | CORE A | 2.5 |
Portillo-RodrÃguez et al. (2010) | Review | Other | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Monasor et al. (2010b) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Lamersdorf and Munch (2009) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Martignoni (2009) | Review | Other | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Sinha et al. (2007) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Cook et al. (2005) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | No | Yes | CORE C | 2.5 |
Giuffrida and Dittrich (2013) | Review | Other | Yes | No | No | Q2 | 2.5 |
Cataldo et al. (2009) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Mak and Kruchten (2006) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Simmons (2003) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Clear (2009) | Solution proposal | Experiment | Yes | No | Yes | CORE C | 2.5 |
Vathsavayi et al. (2014) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Costa and Murta (2013) | Review | Other | Yes | Yes | No | CORE C | 2.5 |
Chubov and Droujkov (2007) | Other | Other | Partially | No | Yes | CORE B | 2.0 |
Monasor et al. (2010a) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.0 |
de Souza and Fonseca (2007) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.0 |
Garrido et al. (2012) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.0 |
Pesola et al. (2011) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.0 |
Aranda et al. (2011) | Solution proposal | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.0 |
Wu (2012) | Evaluation research | Theory | Yes | Yes | No | No | 2.0 |
Jiménez et al. (2009) | Review | Other | Partially | No | No | Q2 | 1.5 |
Dullemond et al. (2009) | Other | Other | Yes | No | No | CORE C | 1.5 |
Aranda et al. (2008) | Other | Other | Yes | No | No | CORE C | 1.5 |
da Silva et al. (2010) | Review | Other | Yes | No | No | CORE C | 1.5 |
Aranda et al. (2006) | Other | Other | Yes | No | No | CORE C | 1.5 |
Murdoch and Astley (2004) | Evaluation research | Theory | Partially | No | No | CORE B | 1.0 |
Salger et al. (2010) | Other | Other | Partially | No | No | CORE C | 0.5 |
Paulish (2006) | Other | Other | Partially | No | No | CORE C | 0.5 |
Ali et al. (2010) | Other | Other | Partially | No | No | CORE C | 0.5 |
van Hillegersberg and Herrera (2007) | Other | Other | Partially | No | No | No | 0.0 |
Wang et al. (2012) | Review | Other | Partially | No | No | No | 0.0 |
Tell and Ali Babar (2011b) | Solution proposal | Theory | Partially | No | No | No | 0.0 |